
Audio By Carbonatix
A U.S. judge ordered the Justice Department on Friday to justify its decision to drop criminal charges against Indian billionaire Gautam Adani, declining to rule immediately on Adani's lawyers' request to dismiss the case.
Brooklyn-based U.S. District Judge Nicholas Garaufis said federal prosecutors' May 18 announcement that they would no longer pursue the case, which charged Adani with securities fraud and wire fraud stemming from an alleged bribery scheme, did not sufficiently explain their decision.
"The Government's terse, bland and conclusory statement affords the court neither a sufficient basis to reach any conclusion, nor the opportunity to conduct any analysis of the Government's request for dismissal," wrote Garaufis, who gave the Justice Department until July 13 to submit more information.
The Adani case was brought in 2024 at the end of Democratic President Joe Biden's term.
The decision to drop the charges marked the latest instance in which the Justice Department has sought to end a high-profile white-collar criminal prosecution during Republican President Donald Trump's second term in the White House.
Legal experts say U.S. judges have little discretion to compel prosecutors to continue with criminal cases they no longer wish to pursue, but the charges remain officially pending until Garaufis orders them dismissed.
A spokesperson for the Brooklyn U.S. Attorney's office, which brought the charges, declined to comment.
Adani Group, Adani's company, has consistently denied wrongdoing. Adani himself has not appeared in U.S. court to respond to the charges.
Robert Giuffra, a lawyer for Adani, referred to the letter he wrote to Garaufis on Wednesday, arguing that the case should be dismissed because it was beyond the reach of U.S. law and prosecutors would be unable to prove the alleged bribery in India.
DEFENSE CITES 'LEGAL AND FACTUAL WEAKNESSES'
Adani was charged in 2024 with agreeing to bribe Indian government officials so a subsidiary of his Adani Group could win approval to develop a solar energy plant, then misleading U.S. investors by providing reassuring information about his company's anti-corruption practices.
The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission also brought civil charges. The SEC has reached a settlement in which Adani would pay $6 million and his nephew, Sagar Adani, would pay $12 million.
Adani Enterprises Limited (ADEL.NS), opens new tab has separately agreed to pay $275 million to the U.S. Treasury Department to settle alleged violations of Iran sanctions.
In his June 24 letter to Garaufis, Giuffra said lawyers for Adani and his co-defendants had several meetings with Justice Department officials and submitted nearly 500 pages of materials to convince them that the case was flawed.
"The DOJ’s decision reflects its careful consideration of the indictment’s legal and factual weaknesses," Giuffra wrote.
'PROSECUTORIAL DISCRETION' CITED
In their brief letter to Garaufis last month, senior officials said the Justice Department "decided, in its prosecutorial discretion, not to devote further resources to these criminal charges against individual defendants."
The rank-and-file prosecutors who brought the case did not sign the letter.
Justice Department officials in Washington last year dropped corruption charges brought under Biden against then-New York Mayor Eric Adams over the objections of the career prosecutors who brought the case, several of whom resigned.
Latest Stories
-
Gov’t prepares to evacuate nearly 900 nationals from South Africa ahead of anti-immigration protests
16 minutes -
Sales assistant fined GH¢12,000 after stealing GH¢353,471 from employer in marriage scam
20 minutes -
GCAA probes alleged mistreatment of KLM passengers after Amsterdam delay
28 minutes -
NRSA Director-General outlines reforms to reduce road carnage
32 minutes -
Kumasi tomato traders push for revival of local tomato industry
33 minutes -
Peace Council establishes peace committee, monitors to strengthen peace efforts
35 minutes -
My agenda is to reunite, restructure, restrengthen NPP – Paul Afoko
36 minutes -
GJA condemns Kasoa Radio attack, demands transparent probe, protection for journalists
39 minutes -
Akan NPP vets 20 aspirants for constituency executive elections
42 minutes -
Biakoye NPP constituency election heats up as 28 aspirants file nominations for executive positions
46 minutes -
Former GRIDCo CEO urges stronger workplace safety laws
51 minutes -
DR Congo superfan denied US visa to support team at World Cup
59 minutes -
Oil climbs following renewed US, Iran strikes in Middle East
1 hour -
Extreme heat costing cities up to 8% of GDP and hitting women hardest, report says
1 hour -
South Africa’s defeat marks World Cup farewell for coach Broos
1 hour