Audio By Carbonatix
The late Pope John Paul II was warned about allegations of sexual impropriety by then-Archbishop Theodore McCarrick, but chose to promote him to Archbishop of Washington anyway following McCarrick's own denials and an investigation by American bishops that returned "inaccurate and incomplete information," an internal Vatican investigation concluded Tuesday.
The report into the Vatican's handling of the highest ranking church figure to be defrocked over sexual abuse comes after two years of investigation.
Raised to cardinal in 2001 by John Paul II, a year after he became Archbishop of Washington, McCarrick went on to become a power player both in the church and in Washington, known for his fundraising and influence.
Vatican admits Pope John Paul II was warned about abusive archbishop Theodore McCarrick, while clearing Francis @deliacnn https://t.co/ED1kkstNSi
— Father Edward Beck (@FrEdwardBeck) November 10, 2020
The report largely appears to absolve the current pope, Francis, from blame.
McCarrick resigned from the College of Cardinals in 2018 and was defrocked by the Vatican last year after a church trial found him guilty of sexually abusing minors.
"Until 2017, no one provided Pope Francis with any documentation regarding allegations against McCarrick," the report's executive summary says.
"Pope Francis had heard only that there had been allegations and rumors related to immoral conduct with adults occurring prior to McCarrick's appointment to Washington," the report says, adding that Francis at first believed "that the allegations had already been reviewed and rejected by Pope John Paul II.
"The report claims that Pope Benedict XVI asked for McCarrick's resignation in 2005 after "accusations of harassment and abuse towards adults began to surface once again.
"The report claims that the Vatican's Office for Bishops told McCarrick orally in 2006 and in writing in 2008 to retire from public life, but that he ignored those recommendations.
The report says that Pope Francis was also aware of "rumors related to immoral conduct with adults" prior to McCarrick's appointment to Washington but decided not take any further action to modify "the course adopted by his predecessors.
"When the first accusation of sexual abuse of a minor emerged in 2018, Pope Francis' response was "immediate" according to the report, and he dismissed the former Cardinal from the priesthood.
Latest Stories
-
71% of Ghanaians worried about rising food prices, despite 68% approval for Mahama – IEA survey
4 seconds -
Antoine Semenyo enjoying ‘fairytale’ start to Manchester City career
26 minutes -
Semenyo is an ‘incredible signing’ – Pep Guardiola on Ghanaian forward
37 minutes -
ASID 2026: Leaders urge stronger laws to protect children online
48 minutes -
Mohammed Fuseini scores in Royale Union Saint-Gilloise win over Charleroi
53 minutes -
Galamsey emerges as Ghana’s second biggest concern, 30% of citizens say – IEA survey
1 hour -
Ghanaians identify unemployment as most pressing issue under Mahama gov’t – IEA survey
1 hour -
Unemployment tops list of Ghana’s most pressing problems, 46% say – IEA poll
1 hour -
68% of Ghanaians approve of President Mahama’s performance despite cost of living concerns – IEA survey
1 hour -
Zaato questions arrest of Ex-NEIP boss, warns of ‘creeping danger’ to Ghana’s democracy
1 hour -
Today’s Front pages: Thursday, February 12, 2026
2 hours -
Bekwai MP visits schools affected by rainstorm, pledges immediate support
2 hours -
IMCC, MoE begin preparation of bill to devolve education sector
2 hours -
50-year-old woman killed in bush at Gomoa Potsin; suspect arrested
3 hours -
GWL moves to restore water supply to Teshie-Nungua as talks advance on desalination plant
3 hours
