This is a short postscript to my earlier note on Ghana’s proposed e-Levy.
In view of certain reactions to that piece, I felt that a quick span of the experiences of other countries that have gone this route, which I had suggested offhandedly in my note, would actually illuminate some of the points rather well. So here goes.
There are, near as I can tell, seven countries in Africa that have imposed or set in motion plans to impose mobile money taxes:
- Kenya imposes a 12% excise tax on transaction fees a while back. Whilst such excise taxes end up being passed on to consumers, and therefore can be retrogressive, the net absolute effect might still be smaller as when competition succeeds in bringing down fees the tax effects will reduce automatically. Moreover, after all, they apply to income earned and not just movement of funds.
- Uganda attempted to impose a 2% fee on transaction value but retreated after a massive public backlash to 0.5%.
- Malawi imposed a 1% fee on transaction value and has since retreated.
- Tanzania wanted to introduce a graduated levy of between 0.43 cents and 4.35 USD depending on the amount being sent. The President has asked that this be reviewed downwards. Reduction in transaction volumes and value have already greeted the policy announcement.
- Zimbabwe has a 2% fee on transaction value.
- The remaining countries – Cote D’Ivoire, Congo Brazzaville and DRC – apply the tax on the mobile operator’s turnover.
None of these countries make significant revenue from e-Money related taxes, yet there is considerable evidence of significant distortions of the digital economy since the imposition of these taxes.
- Kenya makes less than $100m a year.
- Uganda is around $27m a year (total transaction volume has fallen by about 27% in recent times).
- In Zimbabwe, the 2% intermediated mobile tax is on course to yield about $50 million by the end of this year.
Ghana’s projected $1.15 billion return is, as should be clear from the foregoing, completely out of line with experiences elsewhere and a sign of weak policy formulation and prior research.
If actual outturn follows the experience of the country’s Communications Service Tax (CST, aka “Talk Tax”), where wildly optimistic expectations failed to pan out, we may end up with something in the region of say, $150m, and yet would be paying $40m to prevent vaguely defined “evasion”. The $40 million set aside for collection of the e-Levy is aggravating general discomfort about the whole enterprise. Given that the budget was expected to pass around next week and implementation of the tax meant to start on 1st January 2022, it is hard to believe the Government when it says that an open, competitive and transparent procurement process had been planned. How long does it take to even write up the Terms of Reference for a serious Expression of Interest (EOI) process?
All this makes one worry that the planned $40 million e-Levy administration service could end up as badly for the country in ratio terms as the CST revenue monitoring situation involving Subah, Kelni GVG and Afriwave. At one point, the country was spending $32 million in various electronic revenue protection measures, none of which made technical sense, yet total CST take was still hovering in the region of $54 million (2017). That is to say, Ghana was spending more than half of the money it was collecting on policing the same money.
Historical experience, like cross-country comparative experience, counsel serious caution and widespread consultation about how the country goes about designing and implementing any digital tax measures.
If these measures are motivated purely by problem-solving, rather than by procurement opportunities, then why is extensive stakeholder consultation always so hard?
- EC Chair and deputies file suit to halt impeachment proceedings
- We have moles amongst NPP MPs – Muntaka Mubarak
- GFA sacks Milovan Rajevac, management committee to be reconstituted
- Persons without proof of Covid-19 vaccination will not enter Parliament – Speaker
- E-Levy: We’ll pass it, Minority can’t do anything – Stephen Amoah
- Why Dede Ayew is trending on Twitter
- Three students of Ejisu SHTS stabbed in three separate incidents
- Mobile Money Association petitions Minority to reject E-levy
- Resignation of senior doctors at West Gonja Hospital sparks unrest among doctors
- Speaker has been asked to provide information on ambulance issue – Muntaka Mubarak
Vodafone Ɛɛkɔso promo rewards over 175,000 customers
New law to regulate transportation of explosives, mining industry in the offing – Akufo-Addo
Earning salary only manages poverty – Paul Mante
68.2% of households incomes decreased during peak of Covid -19 – GSS survey
Global Media Alliance bags IPR’s PR Consultancy of the Year Award
Access Bank staff support 12 schools with infrastructure and education materials
Nigerians sign petition to scrap English language test
Majorel enters Ghana, further consolidating its leading position in Africa
‘Andre and Jordan Ayew are still committed to the Black Stars’ – Fiifi Tackie
‘Household incomes incessantly reduced post-Covid-19’ – GSS
Biden to nominate first black woman to top US Court
Ghana is a key partner in deepening global, regional economic and security matters – US Secretary of State
Group re-appears with mats and pillows to picket Parliament over E-Levy
I spent 50% of my 8-year savings in 2 years – Family man recounts how he survived Covid-19
‘Ivory Coast is ready to challenge for 2023 AFCON’ – Patrice Beaumelle