Policy analyst, Bright Simons says government’s projected $1.15 billion returns from the imposition of the proposed 1.75% E-Levy is completely out of line with experiences elsewhere and a sign of weak policy formulation and prior research.
According to him, if government had diligently investigated the proposed levy, including taking into consideration the experiences from other African countries where such a levy has been imposed, they would have realised that it is largely impossible for the country to make such returns.
He stated that instead of high returns, most countries that had instituted the levy had witnessed a significant distortion of their digital economies, with Uganda particularly experiencing a reduction in the volume of digital transactions by about 27%.
“If actual outturn follows the experience of the country’s Communications Service Tax (CST, aka ‘Talk Tax’), where wildly optimistic expectations failed to pan out, we may end up with something in the region of say, $150m, and yet would be paying $40m to prevent vaguely defined ‘evasion’,” he said.
He added that it was also rather suspicious that for a budget that was supposed to be passed around next week for full implementation on January 1, 2022, government has been able to plan an “open, competitive and transparent procurement process” for it.
“How long does it take to even write up the Terms of Reference for a serious Expression of Interest (EOI) process?”
Bright Simons explained that the prevailing situation raised concerns that the “$40 million e-Levy administration service could end up as badly for the country in ration terms as the CST revenue monitoring situation involving Subah, Kelni GVG, and Afriwave.”
“At one point, the country was spending $32 million in various electronic revenue protection measures, none of which made technical sense, yet total CST take was still hovering in the region of $54 million (2017).
“That is to say, Ghana was spending more than half of the money it was collecting on policing the same money,” he said.
“Historical experience, like cross-country comparative experience, counsel serious caution and widespread consultation about how the country goes about designing and implementing any digital tax measures,” he added.
He further stated that if government was really interested in solving a problem, “rather than by procurement opportunities, then why is extensive stakeholder consultation always so hard?”
Latest Stories
- Fuel prices to increase by 7%-13% from February 1, 2023 – IES
6 hours - Finance Minister may attempt to woo individual bondholders with new terms – Martin Kpebu
6 hours - Education Ministry cautions against payment of money for school placement
8 hours - Full list of winners at 47th SWAG Awards gala
9 hours - Playback: The Probe discusses Domestic Debt Exchange Programme
9 hours - Dr Ibn Kailan Abdul-Hamid appointed Head of UPSA’s Department of Marketing
9 hours - Debt Exchange Programme: Article 71 Office Holders must take a 50% haircut – Labour Federation
10 hours - CHAN 2022: CAF confirms change in kickoff time for final
10 hours - Newcastle sign Everton forward Anthony Gordon in £45m deal
11 hours - ‘We wanted a fresh start in 2023, but we have been worse’ – Klopp
11 hours - Brighton knock holders Liverpool out of FA Cup
11 hours - Moises Caicedo made ‘mistake’ asking to leave Brighton, says Roberto de Zerbi
11 hours - Pedri winner extends Barca’s La Liga advantage
11 hours - Chelsea sign teenage right-back Malo Gusto from Lyon in £31m deal
11 hours - Ghana signs agreements with Saudi Arabia on Hajj 2023
12 hours