Audio By Carbonatix
A female civil servant's response to a schoolgirl's request for free sanitary pads has sparked backlash in India.
The teenager made the request at a workshop organised with Unicef in the eastern state of Bihar.
The official responded by saying the girl would soon expect the government to provide free clothes, shoes and even condoms.
Periods are a taboo topic in India, with menstruating women often forced to live under severe restrictions.
Nearly 23 million girls drop out of school annually after they start their periods due to a lack of access to menstrual hygiene facilities.
In Bihar, one of India's poorest states, only 59% of women use a hygienic method of menstrual protection, according to the latest National Family Health Survey (NFHS-5), the most comprehensive household survey of health and social indicators by the government.
At Tuesday's Sashakt Beti, Samriddh Bihar (Empowered Daughters, Prosperous Bihar) event in the state capital, Patna, the student asked senior official Harjot Kaur Bhamra if the government could provide girls with free sanitary pads that cost 20-30 rupees ($0.25-$0.37; £0.23-£0.34) in the market.
The student also spoke about the broken toilets at her school and the difficulty in using them. Reports say the audience mainly comprised 15 and 16-year-old students.
Ms Bhamra, who is a senior bureaucrat in the women and child welfare ministry and heads the Women and Child Development Corporation in the state, seemed to be annoyed by the schoolgirl's questions.
"Why do you need to take everything from the government?" she said. "This way of thinking needs to change. Do it yourself."
When the teenager persisted in asking for solutions from the government which is voted in by the citizens, Ms Bhamra responded in anger: "This is height of stupidity. Don't vote, then. Become Pakistan. Do you vote for money and services?"
After a video of her exchange was shared on social media, many called her comments "shameful" and said the officer was "unfit" to be a public servant.
Ms Bhamra later claimed that reporting on the event was "false, malicious and wrong" and threatened to take legal action against a Hindi newspaper which first reported her comments.
"I am known to be one of the most vociferous champions of women's rights and empowerment," she said, and blamed "mischievous elements" for trying to "malign" her reputation.
Latest Stories
-
GPL 2025/26: Mensah brace fires All Blacks to victory over Eleven Wonders
17 minutes -
This Saturday on Newsfile: Petitions against the OSP, EC heads, and 2025 WASSCE results
44 minutes -
Ambassador urges U.S. investors to prioritise land verification as Ghana courts more investment
1 hour -
Europe faces an expanding corruption crisis
1 hour -
Ghana’s Dr Bernard Appiah appointed to WHO Technical Advisory Group on alcohol and drug epidemiology
2 hours -
2026 World Cup: Ghana drawn against England, Croatia and Panama in Group L
2 hours -
3 dead, 6 injured in Kpando–Aziave road crash
2 hours -
Lightwave eHealth accuses Health Ministry of ‘fault-finding’ and engaging competitor to audit its work
2 hours -
Government to deploy 60,000 surveillance cameras nationwide to tackle cybercrime
2 hours -
Ghana DJ Awards begins 365-day countdown to 2026 event
2 hours -
Making Private University Charters Optional in Ghana: Implications and Opportunities
2 hours -
Mampong tragedy: Students among 30 injured as curve crash kills three
3 hours -
Ken Agyapong salutes farmers, promises modernisation agenda for agriculture
3 hours -
Team Ghana wins overall best project award at CALA Advanced Leadership Programme graduation
3 hours -
FIFA gives President Donald Trump a peace prize at 2026 World Cup draw
3 hours
