Audio By Carbonatix
Prince Andrew is to face a civil case in the US over allegations he sexually assaulted a woman when she was 17.
Virginia Giuffre is suing the prince, claiming he abused her in 2001.
His lawyers said the case should be thrown out, citing a 2009 deal she signed with convicted sex offender Jeffrey Epstein. But a New York judge ruled that the claim could be heard.
He has consistently denied the claims. Buckingham Palace said it would not comment on an ongoing legal matter.
The motion to dismiss the lawsuit was outlined in a 46-page decision by Judge Lewis A Kaplan of the United States District Court for the Southern District of New York.
It means the case against the Duke of York, 61, could be heard later this year.
In court documents, Ms Giuffre said she was the victim of sex trafficking and abuse by late billionaire financier Epstein.
Part of her abuse involved being lent out to other powerful men, she alleges.
Prince Andrew, the Queen's second son, said in an interview with BBC Newsnight in 2019 that he had no recollection of ever meeting Virginia Giuffre, and her account of them having sex "didn't happen".
His lawyers had argued that Ms Giuffre agreed in court in 2009 not to sue anyone else connected to Epstein when she settled her damages claim against the billionaire sex offender.
During a virtual hearing, they said the Duke of York was a "potential defendant" as defined by the agreement and the case "should be dismissed".
Ms Giuffre's lawyer said only the parties of the settlement agreement could benefit from it, and not a "third party".
In his decision, Judge Kaplan said the agreement "cannot be said" to benefit the Duke of York.
He said his ruling did not consider the "defendant's efforts to cast doubt on the truth of Ms Giuffre's allegations, even though his efforts would be permissible at trial".
He added: "In a similar vein and for similar reasons, it is not open to the court now to decide, as a matter of fact, just what the parties to the release in the 2009 settlement agreement signed by Ms Giuffre and Jeffrey Epstein actually meant."
This outcome means difficult days and big decisions ahead for Prince Andrew.
Trying to block the case using the deal between the dead paedophile Jeffrey Epstein and Virginia Giuffre was already heavy with reputational risks.
With that rejected, the case against him will push ahead and lawyers for Ms Giuffre and Prince Andrew will start testing each others' stories, requiring detailed personal evidence.
A civil trial in New York in the autumn is now on the horizon, where Ms Giuffre can put her allegations.
Prince Andrew, who has strongly rejected any wrongdoing, will have the chance to publicly clear his name.
But it's hard to imagine the royal family would want to see a bruising cross-examination in a New York courthouse.
That could mean an out-of-court settlement. But that's not the best look either, leaving the allegations unresolved.
Good options are in short supply for a prince under pressure.
Prince Andrew withdrew from public duties soon after his 2019 Newsnight appearance.
He used the interview to re-iterate his denials of Ms Giuffre's claims and explain his one-time friendship with Epstein and the financier's girlfriend Ghislaine Maxwell.
In December, a jury in New York convicted Maxwell of procuring teenage girls for Epstein.
Latest Stories
-
Photos: Republic Bank, Multimedia Group sign 3-year deal to launch JoyNews Habitat Fair partnership
56 seconds -
Continuity: The engine of compounding
6 minutes -
AI offer lifeline to developing economies in an era of weak growth – World Bank
15 minutes -
Forefathers built better roads with less education than today’s educated generation – Prof Bokpin
17 minutes -
Kayayei interventions must go beyond skills training – Vice President
21 minutes -
Former Nandom MP Ambrose Dery declares intention to contest again in 2028
29 minutes -
GSE delivers 75% year-to-date return for investors as of July 2026
32 minutes -
IDEG: NDC, NPP disagreement over local elections hindering decentralisation reforms
36 minutes -
Wontumi appeal has no reasonable chance of success – AG opposes bail application
39 minutes -
2026 National Youth Conference: Osman Ayariga challenges youth to prioritise character and patriotism
40 minutes -
2026 National Youth Conference: Osman Ayariga calls for stronger youth participation in decision-making
41 minutes -
MTN Ghana delivers strong H1 2026 performance driven by data, digital and fintech growth
43 minutes -
GNFS rescues fuel tanker driver and mate in Tamale
43 minutes -
Comparing ourselves to NPP is setting the bar at ground level, NDC must aim higher – Opong-Fosu
50 minutes -
GAUA strike: KNUST administration offices opened but essential IT services hampered
54 minutes