Audio By Carbonatix
Visiting a doctor for a general check-up is unlikely to lead to a condition needing treatment being identified, but may cause undue stress, say experts.
The Danish researchers that carried out the latest review, which involved more than 180,000 patients, say doctors should stop offering such check-ups.
Health MoTs did not reduce deaths overall or deaths from cancer and heart disease, according to their review.
In England, people aged 40-74 are offered a free health check.
The initiative, launched in 2009, is designed to spot conditions such as heart disease, stroke and diabetes by looking for silent risk factors such as high blood pressure and cholesterol.
Ministers have said the scheme could save 650 lives a year.
But the latest findings suggest routine checks may be a waste of time.
'No benefit'
This could be because of the types of people who take up the offer of screening, say the researchers.
It may be the "worried well" - people who are fit and take an interest in their own health - who attend while those who are at high risk of serious illness keep away.
Or it might be that genuine health problems are spotted at other times - when patients present with symptoms, for example.
Lead researcher Lasse Krogsboll, of the Nordic Cochrane Centre in Denmark, said: "A likely explanation is that physicians are doing a good job of preventing illness anyway.
"From the evidence we've seen, inviting patients to general health checks is unlikely to be beneficial.
"We're not saying that doctors should stop carrying out tests or offering treatment when they suspect that there may be a problem.
"But we do think that public healthcare initiatives that are systematically offering general health checks should be resisted."
He said any screening programme should be able to prove the benefits outweighed any potential harm, such as anxiety or over-treatment.
A Department of Health representative told BBC News: "By spotting people who are at risk of heart attacks, diabetes, stroke and kidney disease we can help prevent them.
"The NHS Health Check programme is based on expert guidance. Everyone having a health check is offered tailored advice and support to manage or reduce their risk of developing serious health conditions. "
The review looked at health checks offered in a number of countries, including some pilot trials in the UK a decade or more ago.
DISCLAIMER: The Views, Comments, Opinions, Contributions and Statements made by Readers and Contributors on this platform do not necessarily represent the views or policy of Multimedia Group Limited.
Tags:
DISCLAIMER: The Views, Comments, Opinions, Contributions and Statements made by Readers and Contributors on this platform do not necessarily represent the views or policy of Multimedia Group Limited.
Latest Stories
-
Ghana pursuing pragmatic foreign policy, not ideological alliances – Mahama
12 minutes -
“Trials have tested me, NPP has trusted me, I am here to deliver” – Chairman Wontumi tells delegates
26 minutes -
NHIS registers 1.48 million subscribers in Ashanti Region during King’s Month campaign
32 minutes -
2 suspected robbers arrested in Upper West, stolen motorbike recovered
32 minutes -
Republic Bank brings clean water to Pwalugu, Dingoni with mechanized borehole projects
32 minutes -
IMANI PULSE: Ghana’s Political conversation is shifting from personalities to performance
36 minutes -
Cabinet gives green light for MMDCEs to be elected; amendments to be laid in Parliament before end of 2026
37 minutes -
Luv/Nhyira FM thrill football fans with ‘Rep your Jersey’ UEFA Champions League Final experience
45 minutes -
Religious leaders warn against politicisation of prophecy
53 minutes -
NPP petitions Chief Justice for removal of Circuit Court Judge over Abronye’s case
55 minutes -
Rotary Club of Kumasi East supplies Psychiatric medication to KATH to improve mental health service
58 minutes -
20% fare hike illegal; disregard any increment – Transport operators
58 minutes -
Joy FM to roll out Father’s Day Safari Escape on June 20 and 21
59 minutes -
George Asare-Afriyie Writes: The Journey towards 97 years of legacy of St. Augustine’s College
60 minutes -
Health Ministry, Parliament, UNFPA intensify fight against obstetric fistula
1 hour