Audio By Carbonatix
Prince Harry cannot broaden legal action against News Group Newspapers (NGN) to include new allegations against Rupert Murdoch, the High Court has ruled.
On Tuesday, Mr Justice Fancourt said the claims about Mr Murdoch's alleged knowledge of unlawful activity at the group added "nothing material" to the case.
Harry and several others are suing NGN - publisher of the Sun and the defunct News of the World - over allegations of phone hacking and unlawful information gathering.
A spokesman for NGN, which denies the allegations, said the court had "thoroughly vindicated" the group's position by refusing permission to introduce "large and significant" amendments to the case.
The Duke of Sussex was further refused permission to push the timeline of the case back to 1994 and 1995, to include allegations involving his late mother, Princess Diana, as the judge said it was "too late".
He was also denied permission to amend the lawsuit to add new allegations that the Sun ordered private investigators to target his then girlfriend – and now wife Meghan – in 2016.
But the duke was granted permission to alter his case to include allegations the papers had tapped his landline phones, and to make further accusations against journalists and private investigators.
Earlier this year, lawyers representing a number of claimants suing NGN claimed that Mr Murdoch knew of unlawful activity as early as 2004 but "turned a blind eye" to the allegations while overseeing a "culture of impunity" at the publisher.
In court documents, a lawyer for the Duke of Sussex argued it could be inferred that Mr Murdoch "was aware of the nature and extent of NGN's wrongdoing" by virtue of his "dominant position" at NGN.
But their request to expand the case was denied, with the judge ruling that allegations against "trophy targets" including Mr Murdoch added "nothing material" to the case.
Prince Harry's lawyers "cannot resist adding more and more detail to the claim, as more and more missing pieces of the jigsaw are found, with a view to having the fullest possible picture to put before the court and be the subject of journalists’ reports and judicial findings," he said.
But "the trial is not an inquiry," he concluded as he denied some of the attempts to expand its scope before the hearing of the claims is expected to begin in January next year.
NGN said: "At a hearing in March 2024, the claimants sought to introduce wide-ranging allegations into their pleadings.
"NGN argued that a number of these were irrelevant to the fair and just determination of claims and had nothing to do with seeking compensation for victims of phone hacking or unlawful information gathering.
"The court in its judgment today has thoroughly vindicated NGN's position and did not give permission to introduce large and significant portions of the amendments."
The News of the World was shut down in 2011 after widespread allegations of phone hacking. NGN has since settled multiple claims with high-profile figures.
Latest Stories
-
Motorists and pedestrians decry worsening encroachment on roads and pavements in Avenor
2 hours -
Mexico beat South Africa in dramatic World Cup opener as three players sent off
2 hours -
Gov’t releases GH¢537m to cover tuition fees of 159,750 students under No Fees Stress Policy
2 hours -
Twice in a year, Chairman Wontumi’s lead lawyer has walked away
3 hours -
CSOs mount strong defence of OSP ahead of Supreme Court verdict
4 hours -
Telecel launches Ashanti Codes to equip youth with digital and AI skills
4 hours -
Cash for awards controversy: Minority demands parliamentary inquiry
4 hours -
Abronye DC granted permission to travel to UK for master’s programme
4 hours -
Government has stabilised economy, jobs will follow — Ricketts-Hagan
4 hours -
World Cup ticket allocations for Ghanaian diaspora not yet received -UN Mission
4 hours -
PURC, ECG and GRIDCo align plans to ensure stable power supply during 2026 FIFA World Cup
5 hours -
Ghana launches National Shea Commodity Platform to commercialise shea production
5 hours -
Bawumia holds talks with British High Commissioner in Accra
5 hours -
AFF study documents 115 edible forest species and indigenous knowledge in biodiversity hotspot
5 hours -
Fortune names Yellow Card among top global crypto innovators
6 hours