Audio By Carbonatix
Elon Musk's X has challenged a New York state law that requires social media companies to disclose how they monitor hate speech, extremism, and other contentious content.
In a lawsuit filed on Tuesday, the social media platform, formerly known as Twitter, argues that the law forces companies to disclose "highly sensitive and controversial speech" that is protected under the Constitution's First Amendment.
New York Attorney General Letitia James, who is in charge of enforcing this law, is the named defendant in X's lawsuit.
Social media sites have become the main source of news for Americans, with the majority consuming it on networks like X, according to new research from the Reuters Institute.
Deciding what content is acceptable on social media platforms "engenders considerable debate among reasonable people about where to draw the correct proverbial line," X said. "This is not a role that the government may play."
The Stop Hiding Hate Act, passed in December, requires social media companies to disclose steps they take to eliminate hate on their platforms, and to report their progress.
In a statement on Tuesday, the two New York state lawmakers who sponsored the Stop Hiding Hate Act called social media companies like X "cesspools of hate speech" and said the law did not violate the First Amendment.
Social media platforms, including X, "have consistently failed to inform the public about their policies regarding hatred and misinformation", Senator Brad Hoylman-Sigal and Assemblymember Grace Lee said.
Neither New York Attorney General Letitia James nor X replied to the BBC's request for comment on Tuesday.
X's lawsuit against New York state comes nine months after the company successfully blocked a California law that required large social media companies to submit reports about their content-moderation policies.
The company extensively cited its earlier victory in its Tuesday's lawsuit and criticised New York lawmakers for failing to revisit the legislation's language even after the California law was largely struck down.
Musk, who acquired X in 2022, has dramatically scaled back the rules that govern what content and behaviours are acceptable on the platform, according to Professor Laura Edelson, who teaches computer science at Northeastern University.
He has "also significantly reduced the resources the platform puts into enforcing even the rules it does still have," she said. "This is why, even though rules around spam haven't changed on X, there is so much more floating around than there used to be."
Last year, a federal judge dismissed a lawsuit brought by Musk against a research group that documented an uptick in hate speech on the site.
Latest Stories
-
Gender Ministry empowers Kayayei with health, financial literacy and safety skills
4 minutes -
‘The law is the law’ – Mahama insists as Asake pleads on Cyborg’s behalf over firearm incident
25 minutes -
Police arrest 2 over illegal possession of 2,600 AK-47 ammunition in Ashanti Region
27 minutes -
Goldbod is rewriting Ghana’s gold story and restoring national value – Senyo Hosi asserts
36 minutes -
Goldbod: Loss or no loss? The price of everything and the value of nothing
41 minutes -
Goldbod’s $214m cost isn’t a loss but a strategic policy investment – Senyo Hosi
42 minutes -
Government settles US$709m Eurobond obligations ahead of due date
42 minutes -
Low inflation and cheaper imports show Goldbod’s true economic value – Senyo Hosi
45 minutes -
VAT reforms: GRA raises registration threshold to GH¢750,000, cuts rate to 20% from Jan. 2026
46 minutes -
Cedi appreciation saved Ghana over GH¢12bn in debt and power payments – Senyo Hosi
51 minutes -
NPP Primaries: Dr Bawumia takes commanding 73% lead — latest Global InfoAnalytics report
58 minutes -
DGPP helped Ghana defy IMF currency forecasts and stabilise the Cedi – Senyo Hosi
59 minutes -
Guinea junta chief wins presidency in controversial election
1 hour -
Cassava from reclaimed mine lands found to contain unsafe cyanide and lead levels – Study reveals
1 hour -
Gov’t settles $709m eurobond payment ahead of schedule – Ato Forson
1 hour
