
Audio By Carbonatix
Hewlett Packard (HP) is seeking $1.7bn (£1.3bn) from the estate of Mike Lynch - who died last year when his yacht sank - over HP's acquisition of his firm Autonomy, the tech giant's lawyers have told the High Court.
HP, now known as Hewlett-Packard Enterprise (HPE), bought Mr Lynch's tech firm Autonomy in 2011, but it says Mr Lynch and Autonomy's former chief financial officer, Sushovan Hussain, misrepresented the company's finances.
In a 2019 trial, HPE had accused Mr Lynch of inflating Autonomy's revenues, which it said forced it to announce an $8.8bn write-down of the company's worth.
Mr Justice Hildyard ruled in 2022 that HPE had "substantially succeeded" in its claim, but that it was likely to receive "substantially less" than the $5bn it sought in damages.
Earlier this year, he ruled that HPE suffered losses amounting to around £700m through the purchase of Autonomy.
Mr Lynch and his teenage daughter Hannah were among seven passengers and crew who died when the Bayesian went down off the coast of Sicily last August during a storm which caused the vessel to capsize and sink.
A hearing in London, which began on Tuesday, will now decide whether Mr Lynch's estate can appeal against the 2022 and 2025 rulings.
In written submissions, Patrick Goodall, the barrister representing HPE, argued that Mr Lynch's estate was liable to pay $1.7bn, which includes around $761m in interest.
He said that Mr Lynch had "not only perpetrated an enormous fraud, but lied about it at every stage".
He said the claimants had spent almost £150m on the legal battle, and were seeking nearly £113m of their costs from Mr Lynch's estate.
Mr Goodall also said that Mr Lynch's estate should not be allowed to appeal against either the 2022 or 2025 rulings.
In written submissions, Richard Hill, the lawyer representing Mr Lynch's estate, said that the $761m in interest sought by the claimants was an "excessive sum... based on a flawed analysis" and that the "legally and economically rational approach would provide for a materially lower figure".
The claimants' position that "they were the victors in this litigation" was "overly simplistic", he added.
Mr Hill also said that Mr Lynch's estate should be allowed to appeal against the two earlier rulings, claiming that the judge "erred in law" and that there was a "compelling reason for allowing the appeal to be heard".
A spokesperson for the Lynch family said: "Today's hearing addresses technical matters that change nothing about the underlying substance of the case.
"The core facts remain that HP's claim was fundamentally flawed and a wild overstatement."
In a separate case, Mr Lynch was extradited to the US in 2023 to face criminal charges, and he was cleared of fraud charges in 2024.
He was celebrating being acquitted on his yacht when it sank.
Latest Stories
-
‘She’s a real Scorpio’: Gen Z’s love for astrology is showing up in their jewelry
4 minutes -
Monday’s floods destroyed everything in my home – Kwame Jantuah
5 minutes -
Bosome Freho District Assembly empowers persons with disabilities with start-up kits to reduce street begging
7 minutes -
Floods, cholera and typhoid: What communities need to know
13 minutes -
Gen Z’s love for retro watches has little to do with keeping time
19 minutes -
Discipline must build unity, not endanger victory: a reflection on leadership, constitutionalism and the future of the NPP
26 minutes -
When the rains come, let us not count the dead again
34 minutes -
People with a lot of unresolved anger usually show it in these 3 surprising ways
44 minutes -
Gonja king calls for stronger collaboration with Asante Kingdom to promote peace and development
50 minutes -
‘Most massive’ Russian attack on Kyiv kills at least 18
53 minutes -
People smuggler convicted in France found by BBC living in UK and seeking asylum
53 minutes -
The 2026 FIFA World Cup… or World War II in Disguise?
1 hour -
We want to be remembered for our unity – Daughters of Glorious Jesus
1 hour -
NACOC reaches out to 50 substance users in Ashanti Region under “Wheels of Change” initiative
1 hour -
Supreme Court dismisses consolidated cases challenging Torkornoo’s removal
1 hour