Audio By Carbonatix
X, formerly called Twitter, has removed a post denying the Holocaust after criticism from the Auschwitz Museum. The social media platform had initially said the post did not break its rules.
The offensive post was a reply to one from the museum about a three-year-old Jewish girl murdered in the concentration camp's gas chambers.
The post called her death a "fairy tale" and used anti-Semitic tropes.
X's policies state that Holocaust denial is prohibited.
At least 1.1 million people were murdered in the Auschwitz concentration and extermination camp in German-occupied Poland. Almost one million were Jews. The museum notes more than 200,000 were children and young people.
They were gassed, starved, worked to death and killed in medical experiments.
According to a post on X by the Memorial and Museum Auschwitz-Birkenau, it had reported the offensive reply but received a response saying that after viewing the "available information" the platform had decided no rules had been broken.
That initial response to the museum's complaint, according to X, was down to a mistake during the first review - it was escalated and removed in a second review.
"Violent event denial" is banned under X's policies on abusive behaviour. The platform says it prohibits content denying that mass murder took place which "includes, but is not limited to, events like the Holocaust, school shootings, terrorist attacks, and natural disasters".
The X account which made the offensive post on Sunday has 20 followers.
While X says it has removed the post, the account was still accessible as of Monday 17:00 GMT. Its other content includes statements and language many would find offensive.
The company says it is reviewing whether the account should be permanently suspended.
Zero tolerance
Elon Musk - who describes himself as a free speech absolutist - denies there has been a rise in hateful posts since he took over Twitter as it was then called. In December, he tweeted that hate speech was down by a third.
X concedes that its team responsible for policing hate speech on the platform is smaller than before Mr Musk took over. But it argues its new approach - which it says centres around a zero tolerance for illegal material, and de-amplifying and removing ads from lawful but offensive material - is more effective.
But others dispute that things have improved.
An Institute for Strategic Dialogue report suggested that there had been "a major and sustained spike in anti-Semitic posts on Twitter" since the company's takeover by Mr Musk in October.
The Centre for Countering Digital Hate (CCDH) has also suggested that Twitter "fails to act on 99%" of hateful messages from accounts with Twitter Blue - the platform's subscription service.
It says that posts containing racist, homophobic, neo-Nazi, anti-Semitic or conspiracy content were still visible days after being reported.
However X Corp has launched legal action against the CCDH, and in a legal letter its lawyer, Alex Spiro, argued that the research was "little more than a series of inflammatory, misleading, and unsupported claims based on a cursory review of random tweets".
The decision under Elon Musk to reinstate previously banned accounts, including the account of a neo-Nazi website founder, has also been heavily criticised.
When BBC Monitoring analysed over 1,100 previously banned X accounts that were reinstated under Elon Musk, it found that 190 of them were promoting hate and violence, including depictions of rape as well as abuse directed at women and the LGBT community.
But X argues the experience of researchers who look for offensive content is different from that of ordinary users who stand little chance of encountering it.
Latest Stories
-
Mahama inaugurates committee to oversee GH¢1bn Bawku Revitalisation Fund
11 minutes -
Berko’s US conviction does not automatically establish Ghana bribery claims – OSP
12 minutes -
Mahama sets GH¢1bn Bawku revitalisation plan in motion
55 minutes -
‘I assure the President of my unwavering loyalty’ – Brogya Genfi after new appointment
58 minutes -
US-tested evidence could strengthen OSP’s case against persons of interest in Asante Berko case – Kpebu
1 hour -
Luv FM-Kel Charcoal Toothpaste High School Debate; OKESS and SAHUS clinch final semifinals spots
1 hour -
KNUST to get GETFund support to complete Teaching Hospital – Education Minister assures
1 hour -
Ghana to build its biggest power plant since independence – Ato Forson
1 hour -
APL demands forensic probe into GoldBod following $1.7billion gold-trading losses
2 hours -
Government workers without valid NIA details risk salary suspension from September 15
2 hours -
OSP must investigate everyone in AKSA deal’s value chain – Mary Addah
2 hours -
Tribute to the late Kwabena Kesse (Stephen Boateng) from the May 9 Foundation and its president, Mr. Herbert Mensah
2 hours -
Naming persons of interest in AKSA case is a step towards accountability – Mary Addah
2 hours -
Recycle Up! Ghana calls for more government support to expand green entrepreneurship
2 hours -
Police arrest two suspects over alleged lynching at Daboya
2 hours