Audio By Carbonatix
A federal judge has ruled that New York City cannot prohibit Uber Technologies and Lyft from deactivating drivers from their apps without advance notice, ruling that the novel law is unconstitutional.
U.S. District Judge Gregory Woods in Manhattan said in a written ruling on Tuesday that the city's law adopted earlier this year benefits a small fraction of drivers while interfering with the ride-hailing companies' right to police the safety of their platforms.
"Uber and Lyft are likely to succeed in showing that the law protects a narrow class of drivers and does not advance the broader social or economic interest which the U.S. Constitution requires to permit the severe impairment of their contracts," Woods wrote.
The judge issued a preliminary injunction blocking the city from enforcing the law, which was set to take effect July 28, pending the outcome of consolidated lawsuits filed by the companies last month.
Lyft said in a statement provided by a spokesperson that "we're pleased the court recognized the serious safety concerns at the heart of this challenge."
Separately, Uber spokesman Josh Gold said: "The opinion underscores that driver fairness and rider safety can and must go hand in hand.”
The New York City Law Department did not immediately respond to requests for comment.
The law, one of the first of its kind inthe U.S., was passed in January after the New York City Council overwhelmingly overrode a veto by former Mayor Eric Adams, a Democrat. Adams had said, opens new tab that the law would create an expensive and unwieldy new bureaucracy to handle wrongful deactivation claims.
The law requires that ride-hailing services give drivers 14 days' notice before deactivating them from apps, with an exception for "egregious misconduct," and potentially rehire drivers deactivated since 2019 solely because they did not receive such notice.
Uber and Lyft in lawsuits filed a day apart in June said that the law violated their due process and free speech rights under the U.S. Constitution. They said the law threatened to undermine their reputation and goodwill while keeping unsafe drivers, including those accused of sexual misconduct, on the road.
Latest Stories
-
Black Stars face Ivorian test as injuries force major squad changes
27 minutes -
Save Nations Foundation donates learning materials to Nooria Islamic Basic School, calls for more support
34 minutes -
From selling food to solving problems: How Esther Owusu Nkwantabisah rethought entrepreneurship
48 minutes -
Explained: Ghana’s water plant deal that produced a $235m judgment debt instead of water for 500,000 people
60 minutes -
High Cost of Domestic Airline Fares: Can government do something about it?
1 hour -
Inflation, cedi depreciation put BoG’s MPC under pressure as policy rate decision looms
1 hour -
Lawyer denies Salomey Baffoe received money from ‘Ghana Jollof’ account operator
2 hours -
Beyond politics: Why Kwame Nkrumah’s ideals still matter for today’s leaders
2 hours -
Top South African policeman charged with sexual offences
2 hours -
More than 170,000 respiratory cases recorded in haze-choked Indonesia
2 hours -
Narrowed space, intolerance – Sammy Crabbe says NPP is driving talented members away
2 hours -
We’re not analytical enough – Sammy Crabbe calls for data-driven decision-making
2 hours -
Tonto Dikeh celebrates Bobrisky as birthday tribute sparks online reactions
3 hours -
Peter Okoye tells court he received over $800,000 in P-Square royalties
3 hours -
I’ve never had problems with artistes – Rema addresses alleged fight with Davido
3 hours