Audio By Carbonatix
A federal jury in North Carolina on Monday said Uber should pay $5,000 to a woman who claimed she was sexually assaulted by a driver she booked through the app, as the company faces thousands of similar claims.
The Raleigh, North Carolina, jury verdict followed a trial that began on April 14. It comes after a separate jury in Arizona earlier this year awarded $8.5 million to a woman who claimed an Uber driver had raped her when she was 19.
Although Monday's award is relatively small, it further establishes that jurors may not hesitate to find Uber liable for assaults by drivers in more of the 3,300 similar cases consolidated in federal court.
Both cases are so-called "bellwethers," or test cases for that litigation, and the verdicts could help determine the value of the remaining lawsuits for any potential settlement or resolution of the cases en masse.
The plaintiff, who is not identified in court filings, claims that upon arriving at her destination in Raleigh just before 2 a.m. in March 2019, her Uber driver grabbed her inner thigh and asked if he could “keep it with him," prompting her to flee from the vehicle.
Uber, which has faced numerous safety controversies, argued during the trial that it is a software company, not a "common carrier" such as a taxi service that has a legal duty to protect passengers under North Carolina law.
Even if the plaintiff proved otherwise, Uber argued, the company is not liable for the actions of an independent contractor.
The company also argued that the plaintiff could not show any harm resulting from the incident, saying her medical history showed longstanding mental health and substance abuse issues prior to 2019.
An Uber spokesperson said the jury's award represents a tiny fraction of the damages sought by the plaintiff and "should further bring these cases back to reality."
"That said, we believe the jury was once again incorrectly instructed on the question of liability and have strong grounds for appeal on that important point," the spokesperson said in a statement.
Lawyers for the plaintiff said the verdict was a clear signal that Uber cannot escape responsibility for its drivers' conduct, and called it shameful that the company had made an issue of the plaintiff's personal history.
Uber is also facing more than 500 additional cases making similar claims in California state court.
The company in September won the only trial to take place thus far in those cases when a jury found that it had failed to put measures in place to protect the plaintiff's safety, but that its negligence was not a substantial factor in causing her harm.
Latest Stories
-
NADMO, Zoomlion Launch “No Do No Do” campaign to tackle flooding in Accra
7 minutes -
Critics should now appreciate government’s swift response to xenophobic attacks – Ablakwa
33 minutes -
GRDA to prosecute encroachers on Tema–Mpakadan railway project
47 minutes -
Over 200,000 children yet to be captured in Volta NIA registration exercise – Interior Minister
53 minutes -
Accra Metropolitan Assembly opens applications for 400 revenue collectors to boost IGF
56 minutes -
From Ghana to Global Health Leadership: How Dr Godfred Boateng is transforming health equity and saving lives across the world
57 minutes -
Wilmar and Ghana Armed Forces secure spots in UGCFL Season 2 Final
1 hour -
NADMO, Zoomlion Unveil ‘No Do No Do’ Flood campaign
1 hour -
We are fully committed to protecting current gains – BoG Governor
1 hour -
Bagbin’s decision to reconsider Anti-LGBTQ+ Bill unprecedented – ACEPA Boss
1 hour -
Ghana-UK Investment Summit signals fundamental transition from foreign aid to trade partnerships
1 hour -
Unidentified man found dead near Cathedral Clinic in Accra
1 hour -
VRA CEO named energy sector Chief Executive of the Year at 10th Ghana CEO Summit
1 hour -
Ghana to establish West Africa Hyundai Manufacturing Plant under South Korea partnership – Ablakwa
2 hours -
Burning waste worsens chronic diseases – Eco Impact Network warns
2 hours