Audio By Carbonatix
A Trump-appointed federal judge has ruled that the US president cannot use the Alien Enemies Act to deport Venezuelan migrants.
US District Judge Fernando Rodriguez said Donald Trump's use of the wartime power was "unlawful" and had been improperly invoked.
The law was written in 1798 to allow the removal of non-citizens in times of war or invasion. It has been used by Trump to deport Venezuelans to El Salvador on the basis they were members of the Tren de Aragua gang and "conducting irregular warfare".
The judge said the act only applied when the US was facing an "armed organised attack", which it is not. The administration has not commented.
President Trump in March issued a proclamation claiming that Tren de Aragua was invading the US, and justified the use of special powers to deport immigrants identified as gang members without court proceedings.
He used the act to deport two plane loads of alleged migrant gang members to the El Salvadoran terrorism prison known as Cecot.
Neither the US government nor El Salvador has provided details of the deportees' alleged criminality or gang membership.
The ruling is the first time a federal judge has ruled the use of the act is "unlawful".
"The historical record renders clear that the president's invocation of the AEA... is contrary to the plain, ordinary meaning of the statute's terms," the judge wrote.
"As a result, the court concludes that as a matter of law, the executive branch cannot rely on the AEA... to detain the named petitioners... or to remove them from the country."
The judge pushed back against the Trump administration's argument that the president's use of the act was beyond the purview of the courts.
"Allowing the president to unilaterally define the conditions when he may invoke the AEA, and then summarily declare that those conditions exist, would remove all limitations to the executive branch's authority under the AEA," he said
He added that allowing such a move would "strip the courts of their traditional role of interpreting Congressional statutes".
The Alien Enemies Act has only been used three times before in US history - during World War Two, World War One and the War of 1812.
Latest Stories
-
Morocco names Tiznit-Dakhla Expressway after Trump
13 minutes -
T-bills auction: Government exceeds target by 79%, but one-year bill yield increases
17 minutes -
ECOWAS donates $250,000 to support Ghana flood victims – Ablakwa reveals
23 minutes -
ISSER questions slow pace of “Big Push” as construction growth remains weak
26 minutes -
Full AfCFTA implementation will transform Africa – Dr Ishmael Yamson
31 minutes -
Mid-Year Budget: Prioritise employment-led growth – ISSER to government
34 minutes -
ARB Apex Bank ready for microfinance supervisory role, posts GH¢34.56m profit in 2025
37 minutes -
Mid-Year Budget: ISSER urges government to prioritise spending efficiency in fiscal consolidation
39 minutes -
MTN Ghana: Ghana Card will detect MoMo loan defaulters who dispose of SIM cards
1 hour -
Fire destroys room and damages home at Teshie Penny
1 hour -
Ministry of Education clarifies basic school language policy, says foreign languages will remain optional
2 hours -
Otumfuo urges KNUST’s new Vice-Chancellor to lead through dialogue, not command
2 hours -
Court of Appeal panel changes are routine, not evidence of interference – Samson Lardy Anyenini
2 hours -
Prof. Christian Agyare officially assumes office as KNUST’s 13th Vice-Chancellor
2 hours -
MASLOC case: Samson Lardy Anyenini explains why Court of Appeal overturned Sedina’s conviction
3 hours