Audio By Carbonatix
South Africa's parliament descended into chaos as leftist MPs scuffled with security during a key annual speech by President Jacob Zuma.
The Economic Freedom Fighters (EFF), led by Julius Malema, repeatedly interrupted Mr Zuma, demanding answers over a spending scandal.
The speaker of parliament then ordered their removal, prompting scuffles.
The largest opposition party, the Democratic Alliance, walked out in protest at their expulsion.
"You can't send police into parliament," said Democratic Alliance parliamentary leader Mmusi Maimane.
The EFF used President Zuma's annual State of the Nation speech to question him about a state-funded, multi-million dollar upgrade to his private residence.
They were evicted by large numbers of security guards. Among those thrown out was Mr Malema.
He defended his MPs actions, calling it a legitimate attempt to defend democracy, adding that seven of his party had been injured and would be pressing charges.



It is not clear whether the guards were police or parliamentary officials: an important distinction, according to one MP, who said the use of police would be a way of intimidating the opposition.
Mr Malema and Mr Zuma were once close allies but the pair fell out.
The EFF has shaken up South African politics with a series of populist proposals to redistribute wealth.


EFF MPs accuse Mr Zuma of benefitting unduly from taxpayer-funded upgrades to his private residence in the village of Nkandla and they wanted Mr Zuma to answer questions about this before making his state of the nation speech.
Last year an independent inquiry found the president had "unduly benefited" from the expensive upgrades, which included a pool and a cattle enclosure and cost about $23m (£13.8m).
The president has denied any wrongdoing.
Despite criticism of the Nkandla upgrade and the country's stagnant economy, Mr Zuma's African National Congress was overwhelmingly re-elected last year.
Latest Stories
-
I don’t mind being insulted; I have a crocodile skin – President Mahama
9 minutes -
Samson’s Take: Verify the badge – and verify the story
21 minutes -
President Mahama explains why Ghana must rethink regulation of TikTok, other new media platforms
32 minutes -
Rule of law must be protected – GBA condemns EOCO action against Baffour Awuah
2 hours -
950,000 barrels of Sankofa crude head to TOR as GNPC deepens domestic refining
2 hours -
Scales of deception removed – Annoh-Dompreh attacks new cocoa price
2 hours -
Young Positivist Writes : My Experience with GCLP
4 hours -
Strong Day 1 turnout sets tone for Day 2 of Republic Bank-JoyNews Habitat Fair Clinic
4 hours -
Ghana Army warns new soldiers against social media misuse, uniform abuse
4 hours -
AMA calls for science-led action to tackle environmental health risks in Accra
4 hours -
NPP Canada Organizer BigMo urges Diaspora to support Kodua Frimpong
5 hours -
He entered at eight; he is now 16: Ghana’s children growing up in prayer camps
8 hours -
‘Development must not always begin from Accra’ — Anwelle Foundation launched in Jirapa
8 hours -
PKO trio eye victories at Odwira Festival
11 hours -
346 Ghana Navy recruits pass out after 26 weeks of intensive training
11 hours