Audio By Carbonatix
California and Hawaii can enforce bans on carrying guns in some public locations including bars and parks, a federal appeals court ruled on Friday, partly reversing lower court orders blocking the bans.
A unanimous panel of the San Francisco-based 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals ruled that both states can enforce gun bans in bars and restaurants that serve alcohol and in parks, and that California can enforce bans in casinos, libraries, zoos, stadiums and museums. Those bans extend to adjacent parking lots.
The panel said Hawaii can ban guns on beaches, and on private property that is open to the public without explicit permission from the owner.
Both states passed their laws in response to a June 2022 ruling by the U.S. Supreme Court, which found for the first time that the right to bear arms guaranteed by the Second Amendment of the U.S. Constitution includes individuals' right to carry handguns in public for self-defence.
The Supreme Court said any restrictions on carrying guns must be "consistent with this nation's historical tradition of firearm regulation," and could include bans in "sensitive places."
The states argued that their new restrictions qualified.
The lower courts in both states' cases largely struck down the state laws after finding that there were no similar laws at the time the Second Amendment was adopted.
The 9th Circuit panel said that their reasoning was too narrow. For example, it found that parks in their modern form arose only in the 19th century and that municipalities quickly began banning firearms in them.
However, the appeals court upheld portions of lower court orders ruling that neither state could enforce bans on carrying guns in banks or adjacent parking lots, and that Hawaii cannot enforce a ban on guns in parking lots shared by government and non-government buildings. It said that California cannot enforce bans in hospitals, public transit, gatherings requiring a permit and places of worship.
All three judges on the panel were appointed by Democratic presidents.
"This law was never about safety," Chuck Michel, president of the California Rifle & Pistol Association, which had challenged the California bans, said in an email. "The places where permits are now invalid have now become criminal empowerment zones, and the public is less safe in those places."
Michel said the plaintiffs would consider a petition for rehearing in the 9th Circuit or an appeal to the Supreme Court.
"I certainly am happy that they ruled for us on the issue of banks and shared parking lots," said Alan Beck, a lawyer for the Hawaii plaintiffs, adding that the issue of a ban on private property could go to the Supreme Court.
The office of California Attorney General Rob Bonta and Hawaii Attorney General Anne Lopez did not immediately respond to requests for comment.
Latest Stories
-
The Law 101: GBA states pure law and convention about Legal Vacation (Part III)
6 minutes -
Pray – THE LAW 101: The Vacation Roster dilemma and the reality of Court Recess (Part II)
23 minutes -
Trump hid in catering truck in secret plane swap over Iran threat, reports say
29 minutes -
Inside the Secret Service ‘shell game’ to hide US presidents in plain sight
31 minutes -
GEA seeks Gender Ministry’s support for Female Future Programme
42 minutes -
Driver beaten to death over misunderstanding at Gomoa Achiase
52 minutes -
Bagre Dam spillage: 68 communities in Northern region alerted as Burkina Faso monitors water levels
53 minutes -
ECG announces power outages in Central, Eastern and Western Regions on Thursday
57 minutes -
THE LAW 101: Tempus Non Currit – Why the sacred silence of the Legal Vacation protects justice (Part I)
2 hours -
God does not take campaign instructions
2 hours -
Government moves to address rising accommodation costs at KNUST
2 hours -
Cristiano Ronaldo marries longtime love Georgina RodrĂguez in Portugal
2 hours -
Political parties, judiciary must reform themselves to protect Africa’s democracy – Asiedu Nketia
2 hours -
Luv FM High School Debate: T.I AMASS advances as IBASS makes impressive debut
2 hours -
Greater Accra Business Merit Awards honours SIM Group of Companies
2 hours