Audio By Carbonatix
A couple from New Hampshire in England after solving their irreconcilable differences were turned away after they sought to undo their divorce in court.
The state's Supreme Court this month upheld a lower court ruling refusing to vacate a New Castle couple's 2014 divorce after 24 years of marriage.
Terrie Harmon and her ex-husband, Thomas McCarron, argued on appeal that their divorce decree was erroneous because they mended fences and are a couple once more. But the justices, in a unanimous ruling issued Dec. 2, said the law specifically allows them to grant divorces — not undo them.
Courts in some states — including Illinois, Nebraska, Mississippi, Arkansas, Maryland and Kentucky — will vacate divorces within a certain time frame or under certain circumstances, at the parties' request. Others — including New York and South Dakota — maintain they, like New Hampshire, have no statutory authority to undo a divorce.
Attorney Joshua Gordon, appointed to defend the lower court's ruling, said allowing the couple's divorce to be undone could jeopardize the finality of all divorces.
"Divorce is a uniquely fraught area of litigation," Gordon argued. "For divorced couples, it is often important to have the solace of knowing that their former spouse is indeed former."
Harmon and McCarron did not return calls seeking the answer to the question: Why not just remarry?
They were married in 1989 and filed for divorce in January 2014; the divorce decree was finalized in July that same year. In March, they filed a joint motion to vacate the decree.
New Hampshire law does allow for divorces to be set aside for reasons of fraud, accident, mistake or misfortune. Gordon said that none of those circumstances happened in the Harmon-McCarron divorce and that any adverse financial consequences the couple claimed were "self-imposed."
He said it's his understanding they had several reasons for trying to vacate the decree.
"I think it was partly sentimental, and partly that they had some business interests that a divorce and remarry would be more complicated than undoing the divorce," Gordon said.
Harmon, a lawyer, argued in court papers that a couple shouldn't have to show the decree was legally flawed if they reconcile. She said that test is "designed to balance the interests of adverse parties," not those who want to get back together.
Attorney Kysa Crusco, head of the family law section of the New Hampshire Bar Association, said Harmon's argument was "creative" but the law and prior New Hampshire rulings are clear.
"People just have to be cautious in making sure divorce is what they really want," she said.
Latest Stories
-
Thara Mills Simmonds named 2026 Forty Under 40 Achiever in Education
2 minutes -
Ghana deepens diaspora diplomacy: Embassy pledges enhanced consular support for Ohio communities in Columbus
10 minutes -
Ghana’s maternal health success story at risk without rural incentives – UNFPA
11 minutes -
‎Gaps in suicide data affect prevention interventions in Ghana – Accra Psychiatric Hospital MD
12 minutes -
Ghana Armed Forces to participate in Accra-Kumasi Expressway construction – Mahama
12 minutes -
Use chiefs to stop disputes from flooding Ghana’s courts – Deputy AG to governing council of ADR
26 minutes -
Four arrested as police bust alleged kidnapping, torture and extortion syndicate
28 minutes -
NPA increases price floor from September 16; petrol to sell at GH¢16, diesel at GH¢16.77
49 minutes -
OMJ fufils BECEPIP schorlaship promise, awards 12 learners
54 minutes -
Photos: GAF hands over 175.6km right-of-way for Accra-Kumasi Expressway construction to gov’t
56 minutes -
Accra-Kumasi Expressway to be operated and maintained for 50 years through toll revenue
59 minutes -
LGA holds Landmark Conference, AGM and Elections as the Committee on Politics and Elections emerges as the Overall Best Committee for 2025/2026.
1 hour -
JSALK Beverages pays medical bills of struggling nursing mothers at Nkawie-Toase Hospital
1 hour -
Accra-Kumasi Expressway to be operated as business to recover taxpayers’ investment – CEO
1 hour -
UNFPA calls for presidential intervention as maternal deaths reach crisis levels
1 hour