
Audio By Carbonatix
Fiery debate has erupted at the first congressional hearing in a decade to explore whether the descendants of US slaves should be compensated.
Some witnesses said reparations would damage the relationship between white and black Americans, while others said it was imperative to achieve justice.
Several Democratic White House hopefuls have taken up the idea of reparations.
But Republican leader Mitch McConnell has made it clear no reparations bill will pass while he controls the Senate.
The House of Representatives judiciary subcommittee on the constitution, civil rights and civil liberties said Wednesday's hearing would examine "the legacy of the Trans-Atlantic Slave Trade, its continuing impact on the community and the path to restorative justice".
Lawmakers considered a bill proposed by Texas Democrat Sheila Jackson-Lee to set up a commission to study the question of reparations for slavery.
Hundreds of people lined up outside the hearing venue and filled the overflow room to watch.
What are the arguments against reparations?
Republican witness Coleman Hughes, an African-American writer and New York student, argued during the hearing that such restitution "would insult many black Americans by putting a price on the suffering of their ancestors".
"If we were to pay reparations today, we would only divide the country further, making it harder to build the political coalitions required to solve the problems facing black people today."
The second Republican witness, African-American former NFL player Burgess Owens, also rejected the idea, saying: "What strangers did to other strangers 200 years ago has nothing to do with us because that has nothing to do with our DNA."
Congressman Mike Johnson, a Louisiana Republican, was booed as he spoke against "the injustice of monetary reparations from current taxpayers for the sins of a small subset of Americans from many generations ago".
The hearing was held on Juneteenth, which commemorates 19 June 1865 when Texas slaves finally learned they were free, two-and-a-half years after President Abraham Lincoln's Emancipation Proclamation.

Image caption: Actor Danny Glover, whose great-grandmother was a slave, testified in favour of reparations
What was the case in favour?
Actor Danny Glover told the panel that reparations would cure "the damages inflicted by enslavement and forced racial exclusionary policies".
"A national reparations policy is a moral, democratic and economic imperative," Mr Glover said.
Economist Julianne Malveaux emphasised that she wanted lawmakers to address structural inequalities affecting black Americans.
"When zipcode [postal code] determines what kind of school that you go to, when zipcode determines what kind of food you eat - these are the vestiges of enslavement that a lot of people don't want to deal with."
Lawmakers also heard from writer Ta-Nehisi Coates, whose 15,000-word cover story for the Atlantic magazine in 2014, The Case for Reparations, reignited the whole debate.
He said: "Enslavement reigned for 250 years on these shores. When it ended, this country could have extended its hollow principles of life, liberty and pursuit of happiness to all. But America had other things in mind."
Latest Stories
-
GACL reminds public to seek approval for cultural performances at airport
46 seconds -
Russia allocates 120 scholarship slots for Ghanaian students for 2026/27 academic year
58 seconds -
Tourism Ministry takes over former Finance Annex Building to boost operations
2 minutes -
Minority cites ‘major defects’ in Wontumi judgment, vows legal, parliamentary action
5 minutes -
Dozens hurt in Bologna protests after man dies while being restrained by police
6 minutes -
KATH appeals for more support as wheelchair shortage hampers patient care
8 minutes -
AU Health Commissioner pushes for stronger domestic financing of Africa’s health systems
8 minutes -
Reverse illegal deductions from service personnel allowances – Manasseh Azure Awuni to NSA
15 minutes -
Russia, Ghana trade volume rises to over $800m as Moscow seeks deeper cooperation
21 minutes -
GIFMIS trains Social Investment Fund staff to strengthen public financial management
25 minutes -
Why is one judge handling several NPP cases? – Former MP questions Wontumi trial
26 minutes -
AU Commissioner calls for better pay to retain Africa’s health professionals
26 minutes -
Ati-Zigi tops World Cup goals prevented rankings after Ghana’s campaign
32 minutes -
Producer price inflation for June 2026 drops to 3.5%
40 minutes -
National Service Authority denies authorising allowance deductions, says NASPA approved GH¢60 charge
45 minutes