Audio By Carbonatix
The UK must not deport two Somalis convicted of serious crimes because to do so would endanger their lives, the European Court of Human Rights says.
The Strasbourg judges said the UK's duty to protect the two from torture or inhumane treatment was "absolute".
The pair, aged 24 and 42, were served with deportation orders after being convicted of burglary, threats to kill, robbery and dealing in class A drugs.
The ruling sets a legal precedent for 214 similar UK cases involving Somalis.
Abdisamad Adow Sufi (24) and Abdiaziz Ibrahim Elmi (42) are being held at immigration detention centres in the UK.
In 2007 they appealed to the Strasbourg court, arguing that they would face death or serious injury if the UK deported them to the war-ravaged capital Mogadishu.
The seven judges accepted that there would be a violation of Article 3 (prohibition of inhuman or degrading treatment) of the European Convention on Human Rights if the pair were sent back to Mogadishu.
The court ruling said the judges "reiterated that the prohibition of torture and of inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment was absolute, irrespective of the victims' conduct".
"Consequently, the applicants' behaviour, however undesirable or dangerous, could not be taken into account."
UK 'very disappointed'
The court told the UK to pay Mr Sufi 14,500 euros (ÂŁ13,000) and Mr Elmi 7,500 euros (ÂŁ6,716) for costs and expenses.
The UK still has three months in which it can appeal for the case to be re-examined.
The UK Border Agency said it was "very disappointed" at the ruling and was considering its legal position.
"This judgment does not stop us continuing to pursue the removal of foreign criminals who commit a serious crime," it said in a statement. "Nor does it find that all Somalis are in need of international protection."
Somalia has not had a functioning national government for 20 years.
The Islamist al-Shabab group controls much of southern Somalia and has been fighting interim government forces for control of Mogadishu in recent months.
Source: BBC
DISCLAIMER: The Views, Comments, Opinions, Contributions and Statements made by Readers and Contributors on this platform do not necessarily represent the views or policy of Multimedia Group Limited.
Tags:
DISCLAIMER: The Views, Comments, Opinions, Contributions and Statements made by Readers and Contributors on this platform do not necessarily represent the views or policy of Multimedia Group Limited.
Latest Stories
-
NADMO dismisses claims residents were not warned before Weija Dam spillage
1 hour -
Government begins payment of 2020 batch of nurses and midwives arrears
1 hour -
Controversial anti-LGBTQ bill presented to Parliament for second reading
1 hour -
Deloitte Partner urges clear, consistent policies to govern mining license renewals, local content
2 hours -
Xenophobic attacks: Ghana must pursue justice for victims beyond evacuation – Bosome Freho MP
2 hours -
BOPP positions sustainable agribusiness as investment frontier
2 hours -
Ga Mantse demands action against chiefs selling lands on waterways
2 hours -
South African Tourism condemns anti-immigrant attacks, reassures African travellers
2 hours -
APSU 2002 Year Group announces key leadership appointments for 97th anniversary hosting & BOLT Steering Committee
2 hours -
Government backs hybrid model for Ghana’s extractive sector, rejects move to shut out foreign investors
2 hours -
LMWG commends Heath Goldfields on 5-year community development plan for Prestea
3 hours -
Eswatini champions SiSwati stories in digital age at World Book Day 2026
3 hours -
Only weak men forgive cheating partner – Yul Edochie
3 hours -
Meta repeatedly snubs EU body over Facebook and Instagram user bans
3 hours -
Family wealth should be viewed as asset class for building transgenerational enterprises – Alex Dadey
3 hours