Audio By Carbonatix
I have discovered a new word. Well, it is new to me, but I find that it is a word that is supposed to have been in use since 1974. Just tells you how blissfully ignorant one can be.
The word is Whataboutery. Yes, it is a word alright and even though it can’t be found in my old, trusted, dog-eared dictionary that sits on my desk, my phone assures me it is an English word.
Here are definitions offered of three variations of the word in sentences. Whataboutery is deployed by people who are themselves accused of a charge, and who wish to distract rather than defend themselves – it is a misdirection of the guilty.
Whataboutism: blame can be accepted without some finger-pointing immediately following it but, especially online, it is all whataboutery.
Whatabouteries: there was always the lurking suspicion that the promised new approach could not be sustained and that old whatabouteries would inevitably surface.
Now that you have seen examples of how the word is used, here is the official definition of Whataboutery: it is a noun, and it is defined as the technique or practice of responding to an accusation or difficult question by making a counter-accusation or raising a different issue. All too often, the definition continues, well-intentioned debate descends into whataboutery.
I have no idea how I have managed to operate all these years without such an important word in my lexicon. To borrow from Nigel Warburton, the British philosopher whose article introduced the word to me, all current political debate seems to be hinged on whataboutery.
You try to talk about the events that have gripped the whole world, Vladimir Putin’s invasion of Ukraine and the answer is what about the long history of American and British imperialism around the world?
What about the US going into Iraq? Or as someone put it, to understand what is going on, wherever Russia appears, put America and wherever Ukraine appears, put the Middle East.
This presupposes, of course, that I understand what the Americans went to do in Iraq or that I agreed with the invasion of Iraq. It presupposes therefore that whatever reasons I would have had for agreeing with that event, I could use the same reasons to justify the Russian invasion of Ukraine.
I am not sure how helpful the reference is for those who opposed the invasion of Iraq, but by the time you get to that, the debate would have moved on and it would be taken you have been adequately silenced.
Every day when you listen to political discussions in this country, you realise nothing is judged unless it can be compared with what someone or some other group did or said some time ago.
Now that we have this unforgiving Internet, if I am accused of stealing, all I need do is find an example of an opponent stealing. I could have stolen from the orphanage and my opponent could have stolen a makeup bag, once the word steal appears, we are in whataboutery territory and I am free to move on.
Nigel Warburton writes that whataboutery rests on the false premise that wrongdoing is mitigated if others have done something similar and that accusers need to be innocent of the crime of which they are accusing others.
He points out that liars can sometimes tell the truth and those who are immoral or even those who engage in criminal activity are not necessarily precluded from pointing accusing fingers at others’ wrongdoing.
It will be useful if we would just try and judge current events without getting into whataboutery.
I notice that past actions, accepted generally at the time to be wrong, are now being justified on the basis that something similar is currently being done.
Latest Stories
-
USTED dean warns GAUA strike could disrupt Ghana’s restored academic calendar
3 minutes -
Bechem meat processing factory 50% complete, set for March 2027 completion – Kwakye Ofosu
16 minutes -
Titus Glover criticises Mahama’s appointment of Afi Agbenyo as EC Deputy Chairperson
22 minutes -
GoldBod initiative has created over 1,300 public and private sector jobs – Sammy Gyamfi
24 minutes -
Financial wellness key to retaining Ghana’s skilled workforce – Merban Capital CEO, Benjamin Ackah-Nyamike
27 minutes -
Sidney Nii Oko Bampoe & Isaac Akuetteh Addo
34 minutes -
Haruna Iddrisu calls for ‘Big Push’ investment in health, education, sports and agriculture
34 minutes -
Ghanaian youngster Prince Amoako Jnr reaches new milestone with FC Nordsjælland
37 minutes -
Ho Teaching Hospital to get cardiology centre under Ghana Medical Trust Fund
39 minutes -
PAC pushes for effective use of GH¢25m by Tree Crops Development Authority
41 minutes -
UK MEET Fellowship challenges journalists to look beyond AI hype
43 minutes -
Kurt Okraku’s regime has ‘failed to perform’ – Kudjoe Fianoo demands resignation of GFA Executive Council
43 minutes -
Afenyo-Markin’s influence is limited by minority numbers in Parliament – Haruna Iddrisu
46 minutes -
Police administration is doing a yeoman’s job – President Mahama
49 minutes -
GoldBod tells PAC Bank of Ghana authorised its foreign exchange transactions
49 minutes