Audio By Carbonatix
A Facebook executive has denied the social network uses a device's microphone to listen to what users are saying and then send them relevant ads.
Rob Goldman, the tech giant's vice-president of ads, was responding to a tweet by PJ Vogt, the presenter of a tech podcast called Reply All.
Anecdotally, many people report seeing adverts which appear to be related to recent, real-life conversations.
Mr Vogt had asked for details of these specific occasions.
"I run ads product at Facebook. We don't - and have never - used your microphone for ads. Just not true," Mr Goldman wrote.
When another Twitter user asked him if that included Instagram, which is also owned by Facebook, he replied, "Yes."
PJ Vogt got hundreds of replies to his original tweet.
"A co-worker got an ad saying, "So you popped the question!" minutes after he proposed, before he told anyone it had happened," wrote Tori Hoover.
"At work, happened to me though earlier this year. Working as a barista, got a burn, talked to my partner in person about it, went to Target, bought the burn cream, and saw an ad on FB for the exact product I purchased. Never searched for product either," wrote Brigitte Bonasoro.
In a statement on its website from 2016, Facebook denied the practice.
"We show ads based on people's interests and other profile information - not what you're talking out loud about," it said.
One theory is that the ads and their connection to an individual are purely coincidental - that the ad may have appeared before but had not been noticed because it had no prior relevance.
"If you take something that has a tiny chance of occurring and give it enough opportunities to occur, it inevitably will happen," said mathematics professor David Hand from Imperial College London when the BBC investigated whether smartphones were "listening in" to conversations last year.
"We are evolutionarily trained to seek explanations."
Latest Stories
-
GTA sensitises taxi drivers in ‘Know Ghana’ tourism campaign
54 minutes -
Archbishop Agyinasare calls for responsible speech amid growing social media abuse
59 minutes -
‘It will be inexcusable for gov’t not to honour payment of teachers’ arrears by 30th October’ – Haruna Iddrisu
1 hour -
Forbes’ World’s Best Employers 2026: No Ghanaian firm ranked among 900 companies
1 hour -
Electronic processing of teachers’ data: ‘The decision is the Controller’s’ – GES boss
1 hour -
Teachers’ Strike: Haruna Iddrisu questions paper-based processing of promoted teachers’ data
1 hour -
Savannah Region: Kunfusi bridge collapses again, leaving nearly 4,000 residents cut off
2 hours -
Teachers’ strike: GES targets Monday deadline to submit promotion data to Controller
2 hours -
Inflation to average 11.3% in 2027 – Fitch Solutions
2 hours -
I didn’t campaign for NDC to come and do this nonsense – Kpebu on EOCO
2 hours -
Fitch Solutions maintains policy rate forecast of 14% by December 2026
2 hours -
Diaspora Nasara Caucus congratulates Mohammed Ali Suraj, new NPP executives
4 hours -
Dr Antwi-Boasiako’s cybersecurity book showcased at UN crime prevention congress
4 hours -
We will empower the grassroots and protect every vote – NPP’s 1st Vice Chair Kojo Bamba
4 hours -
I do not see myself as better than anyone – NPP’s 1st Vice Chair Kojo Bamba
5 hours