Former Supreme Court Judge, Justice William Atuguba, has criticised the Supreme Court’s handling of the parliamentary vacant seat case, arguing that it overstepped its bounds.
In an interview with JoyNews on November 12, he stated that the issue should have been directed to the High Court, not the Supreme Court.
Justice Atuguba explained that the Constitution provides specific guidelines regarding judicial authority over parliamentary vacancies. Citing Article 130 clauses 1 and 2, he emphasized the legal principle verba generalia specialibus non derogant, meaning that general provisions should not override specific ones.
According to him, Article 130 offers general provisions, but the Constitution explicitly designates the High Court to handle matters regarding vacant seats in Parliament.
This, he argued, means that the Supreme Court should not encroach on the High Court’s jurisdiction in such cases.
He added that the Supreme Court has referential jurisdiction “that is to say this matter which is vacant seat is for the High Court.”
Justice Atuguba further clarified that if a legal ambiguity regarding constitutional interpretation arises in such cases, the High Court should refer only that specific issue to the Supreme Court, rather than the entire case.
He criticised Majority Leader Alexander Afenyo-Markin for bypassing the High Court and taking the case directly to the Supreme Court, adding that if he had presided over the case, he would have referred it to the High Court.
However, the Chairman of the Constitutional and Legal Committee of the New Patriotic Party (NPP), Frank Davies, has disagreed with the former Supreme Court Justice's critique of the Supreme Court’s handling of the parliamentary vacancy case.
In an interview on Joy FM's Top Story, Mr Davies expressed concern over Atuguba’s public comments, noting that it was premature for the former Justice to speak on the matter, describing it as worrying.
“I would have expected that Justice Atuguba would have waited for the reasoning judgment before making this pronouncement. It doesn’t do our justice system any good…I find it very worrying,” he said.
Latest Stories
-
Ghana Athletics misses out on Member Federation of the Year as USA claims top prize
3 mins -
Hassan and Tebogo named World Athletes of the Year
6 mins -
MTN FA Cup Rnd 64: Hearts, Kotoko through to next stage, Samartex knocked out
10 mins -
Ex-NPP Chair for Ajumako Enyan Essiam crosses carpet to NDC, backs Ato Forson
16 mins -
Special voting for Western and Eastern postponed to Thursday over ballot leakage incident
30 mins -
Bawumia makes 2nd return to Ashanti Region as campaign hits final lap
44 mins -
Palmer stars as Chelsea brush aside Aston Villa
2 hours -
Manchester United thump Everton at Old Trafford
2 hours -
EC orders recall and reprinting of Eastern and Western ballot papers due to leakage
2 hours -
Keta Port Project to be commissioned soon!
3 hours -
Malaysia and Thailand flooding kills at least 12
4 hours -
Government reaffirms commitment to integrating innovative green solutions into infrastructure
4 hours -
GCEA 2024 Conference held with election of Kwabena Bempong as new president
4 hours -
Amewu inaugurates 7,000-seater stadium in Hohoe
4 hours -
Bawumia appeals to security personnel, journalists, and health workers to vote for him
5 hours