Audio By Carbonatix
Once a woman agrees to having sex, her partner can legally ignore her if she says she'd like to stop.
At least, that’s the case in North Carolina, where the state Supreme Court ruled that women cannot revoke consent after sexual intercourse begins.
According to the 1979 case State v. Way, "if the actual penetration is accomplished with the woman's consent, the accused is not guilty of rape".
Lynn Schafran, senior vice president of Legal Momentum, said she had never seen anything like this ruling before.
“It is certainly out of touch with the way these case are being considered today,” she told The Independent.
But at least two women have come forward in the last two months alleging that the ruling let their rapists get away with the crime.
Amy Guy told local news station WRAL that her estranged husband showed up at her house one night last year, demanding sex. She consented at first, but begged him to stop when he became violent.
Ms Guy’s husband, Jonathan Wayne Guy, was initially charged with second-degree rape. Pursuant to State v Way, however, his charges were dropped to misdemeanour assault on a female. He plead guilty and is currently serving out a 10 month prison sentence.
Another North Carolina woman, Aaliyah Palmer, recounted a similar story to the Fay Observer. Ms Palmer says she consented to having sex at a party, but asked her partner to stop when the sex became violent. She says he did not.
Despite the fact that he encounter was caught on video, police said they did not have enough evidence for a rape charge. The man who allegedly recorded the video is charged with two counts of being a peeping Tom and illegal possession of peeping Tom images.
Senator Jeff Jackson, who learned of the loophole while working as criminal prosecutor, wants a different outcome for women in the future. The Senator recently introduced a bill that would allow consent for vaginal intercourse to be withdrawn at any time during the act.
“Right now, if a woman tells a man to stop having sex he is under no legal obligation to do so, as long as she initially consented,” he said in a statement. “...North Carolina is the only state in the country where no doesn’t really mean no.”
In fact, at least nine US states explicitly recognise the right to withdraw consent during sex, either via state statutes or court rulings.
In states where the law does not specify either way, says AEquitas CEO Jennifer Long, most courts read the law to mean that consent can be withdrawn.
“Realistically, it’s because it’s sort of something that should be common sense: that you consent until you don’t consent,” she said.
Despite this consensus, Mr Jackson has had little luck getting his legislation passed in North Carolina. He has introduced the bill every year since 2015, only to see it get stuck in committee. There is only one week left in the current legislative session, and his bill has yet to move to a vote.
Still, Mr Jefferson remains optimistic.
“This really shouldn’t be a controversial matter,” he said. “I believe this bill will inevitably pass, and when it does, my bet is it passes unanimously. No one can seriously defend this loophole in our rape law.”
Latest Stories
-
Organisations, individuals must embrace energy efficiency to manage costs, others – Deloitte Consulting Partner
26 minutes -
Telecoms chamber raises alarm over 8,000 annual fibre cuts in Ghana
32 minutes -
Bono East Minister advocates expansion of carbon credit activities to reduce emissions
33 minutes -
Why stay interviews matter more than exit interviews
33 minutes -
Photos: President Mahama unveils PET scan facility at Swedish Ghana Medical Centre
36 minutes -
#OccupyJulorbiHouse Demo: Bridget Otoo and friends win case against Police brutality
37 minutes -
Gov’t to introduce ‘Dig Once’ policy to reduce fibre rollout costs by 60% – Sam George
41 minutes -
Nkwanta South chiefs urged to prioritise peace as 24-hour economy market project takes off
50 minutes -
2026 U20 WWC: Black Princesses to discover group opponents on May 15
1 hour -
MahamaCares extends focus to wider health sector investment – Fund Administrator
1 hour -
UK economy sees surprise growth in March despite Iran war
1 hour -
Nigerian professor jailed 70 months in US for $1.4m fraud
1 hour -
US grief author who poisoned husband sentenced to life in prison
1 hour -
High Court rules police violated rights of journalists and activists during #OccupyJulorbiHouse protest
2 hours -
The law & brands in the age of AI technology
2 hours