Audio By Carbonatix
An African Union summit has opened in Libya amid calls for more African troops to be sent to deal with the crisis in Somalia.
But given the limited mandate of the African Union (AU) force currently in Somalia, and its very limited resources, critics say it is not clear what difference more soldiers would make.
Ahead of the first full session of talks for African leaders in the Libyan coastal town of Sirte, East African leaders in a regional grouping that includes Somalia itself - the Inter-Governmental Authority on Development - called for a boosting of the AU force.
And African Union Commission Chairman Jean Ping told the AFP news agency that Somalia had been "abandoned" to its fate:
"We have a contingent of 4,000 soldiers" in Somalia, Mr Ping said, "when an estimated 8,000 are needed. This summit needs to produce concrete decisions."
Nigeria has been considering sending soldiers to Somalia for some time now, while Sierra Leone and Malawi are also mentioned as possible troop contributors.
But what would more troops do?
Armed opponents of the internationally recognised Somali government attack it almost daily, causing a security crisis that has rendered about three million people, or nearly half the population of Somalia, dependent on aid.
Some aid agencies say Somalia has the worst humanitarian crisis in the world today.
Experienced United Nations disaster relief officials certainly agree that it is "one of the most complex and dangerous" crises.
So the need for "something to be done" cannot be doubted. But what?
The roughly 4,000 African Union troops currently in the Somali capital, Mogadishu, are essentially engaged in guard duties rather than active peacekeeping.
They guard the Somali president and they keep the main seaport and airport in Mogadishu open for business.
Bravery
If these troops from Uganda and Burundi were not there, the Somali government would almost certainly have fallen a long time ago to domestic Somali clan opponents or radical Islamists widely accused of being associated with al-Qaeda.
No-one doubts the bravery of the Ugandan and Burundian soldiers on the ground, or their personal commitment to helping ordinary Somalis
But the African force does not actively intervene to stop fighting between the government and its opponents.
And it does not actively provide physical protection to the hundreds of thousands of people who have fled fighting in Mogadishu in recent months.
It simply does not have the resources to do this - and it probably would not have even if its numbers were doubled to 8,000 soldiers.
Critics of the African Union presence say it may, in the long term, have served as a distraction to solving the fundamental problems.
These are the disputes between domestic Somali clans and the proxy war which two of Somalia's neighbours, Ethiopia and Eritrea, are accused of engaging in on Somali soil either directly or through local Somali allies.
It is the failure of Somali clan leaders and international bodies such as the United Nations to solve these disputes that has opened the door to radical groups such as al-Qaeda - not to mention criminals and pirates - to operate with relative impunity in a "failed state".
Critics of the African Union says its limited military presence may be a convenient fig leaf that allows the wider international community to say "something is being done" while in reality the basic political power struggle remains unresolved - and millions live on the brink of starvation.
Source: BBC
DISCLAIMER: The Views, Comments, Opinions, Contributions and Statements made by Readers and Contributors on this platform do not necessarily represent the views or policy of Multimedia Group Limited.
Tags:
DISCLAIMER: The Views, Comments, Opinions, Contributions and Statements made by Readers and Contributors on this platform do not necessarily represent the views or policy of Multimedia Group Limited.
Latest Stories
-
“Ghana has moved from ICU to wellness center” — Finance Minister declares economic recovery
15 minutes -
Ato Forson highlights “turning point” in economic recovery strategy
19 minutes -
NACSA Seminar: Gender Minister demands an increased role for women to end gun violence
24 minutes -
Full text: Statement on Ghana’s new engagement with IMF
31 minutes -
US trade mission to visit Ghana
1 hour -
Tempane: Three suspects arrested over deadly Worinyanga attacksÂ
1 hour -
EU fines Temu €200m for allowing sale of illegal products
1 hour -
Portugal breaks hottest May day record as Europe swelters in heatwave
1 hour -
KetaFC celebrates “vindication” after Volta RFA Middle League controversy
1 hour -
Professor Joseph Ofori-Dankwa receives 2026 Lifetime Leadership Impact Award
1 hour -
United Pension Trustees advocates menstrual hygiene awareness and support for girls in Juaben
1 hour -
The age when the body starts ageing faster
1 hour -
Controversial Volta RFA verdict triggers calls for GFA intervention
1 hour -
AIMS Ghana, University of Waterloo lead push for stronger mathematics education at HTTMC 2026
1 hour -
NADMO dismisses claims residents were not warned before Weija Dam spillage
3 hours