Audio By Carbonatix
Pop star Katy Perry has lost, for the second time, her years-long trademark case against an Australian fashion brand called Katie Perry.
In a High Court ruling on Wednesday, judges found that designer Katie Taylor had not hurt the US singer's reputation or caused confusion with her clothing brand, which started in 2007.
Taylor, who changed her surname in 2015, successfully sued Perry two years ago for selling merchandise during a 2014 Australian tour, but the ruling was overturned in 2024, with the designer's trademark cancelled.
The new decision found that Perry's reputation was so well-established in Australia that anyone seeing Taylor's clothing brand would not confuse the two names.
"This has been an incredibly long and difficult journey," Taylor said in a statement shortly after the decision.
"But today confirms what I always believed - that trademarks should protect businesses of all sizes."
The case centres around the sale of clothes under the Katie Perry brand in Australia and the sale of Katy Perry-branded merchandise during the singer's tour.
In 2007, Taylor - who went under her maiden name at the time - registered her business name, Katie Perry, and applied for a trademark.
Since 2008, she has sold clothes at local markets, has a website, and maintains several social media accounts under the Katie Perry brand.
But in 2009, lawyers for the Roar singer asked Taylor to stop using her brand and signalled plans to oppose a trademark application, but later dropped legal action.
"I had never heard of the singer when I started my label," Taylor said, with court documents detailing how she first heard of Katy Perry in mid-2008 when the song I Kissed A Girl came on the radio.
"I was simply building a fashion business under the name I was born with."
In 2023, Taylor sued the singer for trademark infringement and won, with the singer's sale of jackets, hoodies, T-shirts and sweatpants during a 2014 tour in breach of trademark laws.
But in 2024, it was overturned on appeal, with judges saying Perry had been using her name as a trademark five years before Taylor started her business.
At the time, Taylor described the case as a "David and Goliath" battle, saying she was devastated by the decision.
On Wednesday, the High Court - in a majority decision - found that given the "heightened strength of the reputation of Katy Perry", that "no ordinary person in Australia... after a moment's reflection" would think Katie Perry products were linked to the US singer.
"This case has never just been about a name," Taylor said.
"It has been about protecting small businesses in Australia, for standing up for what is right and showing that we all matter."
In recent years, Katy Perry has made headlines for a range of reasons, from being mocked for kissing the earth after disembarking a Blue Origin spaceflight to her high-profile divorce from actor Orlando Bloom and her new relationship with former Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau.
Latest Stories
-
Asutifi South launches support for pregnant girls to curb stigma, dropout rates
3 minutes -
GMA raises concern over naming of doctors in Charles Amissah death report, calls for focus on systemic gaps
3 minutes -
GMA calls for sustained investment in health system following Charles Amissah’s death report
5 minutes -
GMA calls for fairness and due process over disciplinary action in Charles Amissah report
15 minutes -
Tourism Minister calls for increased investment in Ghana’s creative sector
16 minutes -
Driver arrested after chasing down child cyclist on footpath
20 minutes -
Police crack Bolga robbery gang, retrieve AK47 and 87 rounds of ammunition
22 minutes -
Top BJP leader’s aide shot dead in violence after Indian state election
23 minutes -
Islamic State-linked women arrive home in Australia from Syria
23 minutes -
Six arrested for impersonating security personnel in Agona Swedru
25 minutes -
6 arrested for allegedly impersonating security operatives at Agona Akwakwa
27 minutes -
Dr Joshua Zaato says “No Bed Syndrome” is becoming an excuse for health system failures
27 minutes -
Bank of Ghana exposure to government debt raises independence concerns – CERPA
30 minutes -
UBIDS launches maiden Economic and Social Policy Dialogue to tackle youth unemployment
32 minutes -
Shell latest oil giant to see profits surge due to Iran war impact
34 minutes