Audio By Carbonatix
Ohio can implement a law requiring social media companies, including Meta Platforms' Instagram, to obtain parental consent before allowing children under 16 to use their platforms, a U.S. appeals court ruled on Thursday.
A 2-1 panel of the Cincinnati-based 6th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals overturned, a lower-court ruling that had put the law on hold at the request of the tech industry trade group NetChoice.
The panel found that the law did not violate free speech protections under the First Amendment to the U.S. Constitution.
NetChoice said in a statement that the court's decision threatens the online privacy and constitutional rights of Ohio residents, but the group "remains fully confident that this unconstitutional law will ultimately be struck down permanently."
Ohio Attorney General Andy Wilson, in a statement, said the decision "gives parents the tools to be involved and provide oversight."
The ruling comes as governments around the world, including in Australia, move to restrict children's access to social media, reflecting growing concern among lawmakers about the platforms' effect on young people's health and safety.
The Ohio case is one of an array of legal challenges that NetChoice has been pursuing to prevent states from implementing laws the authorities say are needed to protect children from the mental health dangers posed by social media.
The Ohio law, known as the Social Media Parental Notification Act, was passed by the state's legislature in 2023 and took effect in January 2024, only to be quickly blocked from being enforced by U.S. District Judge Algenon Marbley.
The law requires operators of websites that can be reasonably anticipated to be accessed by children under 16 to verify their age. It provides an 11-factor list to determine whether a website falls within that definition, along with certain exceptions.
NetChoice, whose members include TikTok, Alphabet's YouTube, and Facebook and Instagram owner Meta, had argued the law was unconstitutionally vague and improperly restricted children's access to content protected by the First Amendment.
But U.S. Circuit Judge Eric Clay, writing the lead opinion, said that while the law does place some burden on protected speech and limits how social media companies prefer to distribute their content, it was narrowly written to address Ohio's compelling interest in protecting children.
"At bottom, the Act imposes a parental consent requirement," he wrote. "That requirement constitutes a marginal burden that precisely targets the multi-faceted problem that Ohio has identified: Children’s unsupervised assent to terms and conditions for use of platforms that take advantage of and harm them."
Latest Stories
-
No democracy can flourish where corruption becomes normalised — Ibn Chambas
23 minutes -
Nicaraguan leader proposes extending presidential term by another year
31 minutes -
Gov’t accepts constitutional amendment for equal voting rights in political party primaries
32 minutes -
Dr. Chambas calls for overhaul of Ghana’s education system to safeguard peace
39 minutes -
400 police officers deployed to support the enskinment of the Kpampayaa Naa Yakubu in Yendi
39 minutes -
Unopened Oforikrom Court facility left vulnerable as cables, generator parts are stolen
42 minutes -
AI offers promise but threatens democracy without ethical leadership — Dr Ibn Chambas
42 minutes -
Photos: Gabon President pays tribute to Rawlings, hails his enduring legacy
44 minutes -
NYA CEO Osman Ayariga announces nationwide Youth Clean-Up Exercise Festival on August 1
46 minutes -
Benz Sprinter carrying 11 school pupils crashes into tipper truck on Dzorwulu–Accra Mall stretch
47 minutes -
Africa’s environmental future depends on empowering girls in STEM – Gabriel Nii Kommey Adams
48 minutes -
GNFS launches digital fire safety compliance system for contractors
54 minutes -
Absa Bank facilitates China-Turkey business mission for Ghanaian businesses
54 minutes -
Drone attack caused fire on gas ships at Mediterranean port, Egypt says
57 minutes -
Academic City lecturer selected for University of Michigan AI fellowship
59 minutes