An unprecedented climate change lawsuit against American oil giant Exxon Mobil is set to go ahead in New York.
The state has accused the company of misleading investors about the potential costs of climate regulation to its business.
Exxon says it shared the necessary information and the claims are politically motivated.
The case is at the forefront of a rising number of legal actions faced by oil and gas firms.
Exxon’s trial on the fraud claims will start on Tuesday and is expected to last 15 days. Former US Secretary of State Rex Tillerson, who led Exxon for a decade, is among those likely to appear in court.
“It’s a major milestone as a part of a growing wave of cases that Exxon and other major oil companies are facing, not only here in the United States, but in fact in jurisdictions around the world,” said Carroll Muffett, president of the Center for International Environmental Law.
Fraud claims
New York’s attorney general filed the financial fraud suit in 2018, after years of investigation by state authorities.
In court filings, the state says internal documents show Exxon evaluated new projects based on forecasts for costs associated with climate change that were lower than those it told investors it was using.
Those calculations made investments appear less risky and more valuable.
“By representing that it was applying higher projected carbon costs than it was actually using, ExxonMobil made its assets appear significantly more secure than they really were, which had a material impact on its share price,” the state wrote.
Exxon does not dispute the claims that it used two calculations to evaluate the cost of potential regulation.
However, the firm argues that those calculations were “proprietary” and investors were not misled.
“Reasonable investors who reviewed ExxonMobil’s disclosures understood that climate risks factored into ExxonMobil’s decision-making, which is all that could have mattered to them,” it says.
Legal experimentation
Activists pressed Exxon for years to be more transparent about how climate change affected its business, partly due to hopes that accurate estimation of the financial risks would shift money to more sustainable alternatives.
Analysts said the New York case is an example of the kind of experimentation occurring as governments seek to hold companies accountable for climate change.
The state of Rhode Island has filed claims against Exxon and BP, citing damage along its coast. Authorities in the Philippines and Canada are investigating fossil fuel companies as well.
In recent weeks, the attorney general in Massachusetts has indicated plans to proceed with a case that accuses Exxon of deceptive marketing.
“Regardless of the outcome [of the New York case] the reality that is clear and not inescapable is that the future of Exxon and [other fossil fuel] companies is filled with litigation and it’s only going to grow.” Mr Muffett said.
Latest Stories
- Corporate institutions urged to implement leadership programmes to equip youth for job market
58 seconds - Medikal bought 6 cars for Shaxi – Shatta Wale
8 mins - VGMA has to come and see me before I get involved in the awards – Shatta Wale
8 mins - We are one people – Bawumia and Mahama laud peaceful enskinment of new Yagbonwura
27 mins - Kylian Mbappe replaces Hugo Lloris as France national team captain
2 hours - AFCON 2023Q: Black Stars hold first training at Baba Yara Stadium [Photos]
2 hours - Alpha Beta Christian College wins 2nd Inter-School Girls Debate Championship
2 hours - Today’s front pages: Wednesday, March 22, 2023
2 hours - NDC Parliamentary primaries: We’re not protecting any sitting MP – Sammy Gyamfi
3 hours - Your electricity bill does not have a party colour – ECG MD
4 hours - MFWA to hold national-level forum on misinformation, peace and democratic consolidation today
5 hours - MFWA builds capacity of journalists in fact-checking
5 hours - We have developed key interventions to safeguard clients pension funds- Enterprise Trustees
5 hours - ECG building dockets on those who have stolen power – Samuel Mahama
6 hours - Digitalisation to help reduce ECG’s commercial losses – Samuel Mahama
7 hours