
Audio By Carbonatix
1. In the 1970s and 1980s, it became clear that commodities like oil, while a boon for nation's economy, can quickly become a headache.
2. The price volatility, exchange rate shocks (including "Dutch Disease"), and various problems associated with overdependency on oil led to "split reporting" in national budgeting and fiscal planning.
3. When Ghana started producing oil in 2010, it followed in the footsteps of countries like Nigeria in splitting macroeconomic forecasts and measures into "oil" and "non-oil".
4. Thus, the Finance Ministry reports "oil GDP" and "non-oil GDP", "oil revenue" and "non-oil revenue" etc. etc.
5. I argue that because of the rapid rise and fall of Ghana's oil industry, this split reporting has become a waste of time. If we must expose commodity risk through the budgeting and fiscal planning process at all, then we should use gold.
6. Yes, this would imply some reclassification of the national accounts, but it would be more honest.
7. Perhaps, we should even go forward and start revising some of the structures we set up around the "petroleum holding funds", "annual budget funding amount", and related mechanisms and pivot to gold, including the setup of a special wing of one of the sovereign wealth funds (maybe GIIF) to take in gold windfalls whilst the price rally lasts.
8. Exhibit one of my evidence stack for these positions is the massive 56% decline in oil revenues in H1 2025. Oil production has been falling by ~7.5% per year since 2019.
9. Oil contributed less than $150m to corporate tax take and just about $370m to overall revenue of about $8bn in H1 2025 (i.e. ~4.5%). What kind of fiscal anchor is that?
10. In 2023, Ghana got just $29m from the oil wealth it says it has been investing since 2010 ("Heritage Fund"). In 2024, it went up marginally to $37m. More pitiable were the returns from the Stabilisation Fund at just $8.7m in 2024.
11. I can understand if Nigeria wants to use oil as the fiscal anchor even though it contributes just about 5% to overall GDP. Oil can provide as much as 65% to government revenues and over 85% of exports.
12. In Ghana, the situation is starkly different. Gold is on course to hit 70% of exports. Oil, by contrast, dropped below 12% in Q1 2025.
13. You may say that oil is in a bear phase and gold is in a bull run, but the data shows that the shift is structural. Gold has been increasing as a share of everything since 2019 and oil has been decreasing markedly.
14. Isn't it time to start recognising the structural exposure to gold risks, in contrast with the declining importance of oil and gas, and shift the fiscal anchor?
Latest Stories
-
Trump seeks $152m to reopen notorious Alcatraz prison
35 minutes -
Ex-Chelsea player Oscar retires with heart issue
44 minutes -
CA Foundation drives constitutional literacy in Kpone Katamanso municipality
49 minutes -
GPRTU to hold talks with Transport Ministry over rising fuel costs
52 minutes -
CUTS International urges gov’t to halt sachet water price hike pending cost review
58 minutes -
Chief Justice: Efficient Judiciary essential to reducing business costs
1 hour -
Bayern grabs 99th-minute winner to cap superb fightback
1 hour -
Ahmed Ibrahim urges Ghanaians to reflect Easter values in nation-building
1 hour -
ECG inefficiencies undermining power supply -Mahama outlines reforms
1 hour -
Lewandowski scores as Barca fight back to defeat Atletico
1 hour -
Lack of private sector consultation undermining economic growth – Jerry Ahmed Shaib
1 hour -
Real Madrid seven points adrift after Muriqi’s late Mallorca winner
1 hour -
Ghana must lead AfCFTA implementation by example – Trade Minister Ofosu-Adjare
1 hour -
Strong Judiciary key to business confidence – Chief Justice Baffoe-Bonnie
1 hour -
Mahama announces 60-Hectare irrigation project to boost tomato production
1 hour