The petitioner in the 2020 election petition says a run-off is required since no candidate in the December 7, polls obtained 50 per cent valid votes cast.
Former President John Mahama's case is that in addition to fundamental constitutional infractions committed by the Returning Officer of the Presidential Election, Jean Mensa, the figures announced in the declaration on December 9, 2020, no candidate got more than 50 per cent of the valid votes cast.
This, he says, as a constitutional consequence, a run-off election would be required.
These were contained in former President John Dramani Mahama, the petitioner’s closing address filed by his lawyers at the Supreme Court.
Mr Mahama argued that the evidence from the terms of the declaration and the consideration that the EC Chairperson said was the basis of the declaration reveals that “Nana could only be credited with 49.625 per cent of the votes at the time.”
Mr Mahama said, “The fact that he did not indicate in his Petition what he or the other candidates should have obtained compared to numbers declared by the EC, does not mean that the declaration by the EC Boss is constitutional.”
According to Mr Mahama his own figures are “not relevant to determining whether that claim is well-founded or not.”
The petitioner invited the court to take judicial notice of the fact that ahead of the December 7, 2020 elections, political parties were urged not to seek to announce results based on figures they had collated but to wait for the official declaration of the EC Boss as the returning officer for the Presidential Election.
He explained that the EC under provisions of Articles 43-54, 56 (7), 63 and 65 of the Constitution and CI 127 is charged with the conduct of the Elections.
Mr Mahama said “the starkly untenable nature of the claim that the petitioner should have put towards his own figures is put in sharp relief when it is recalled that, by virtue of Article 64 (1) of the Constitution, any citizen of Ghana can present a petition challenging the validity of the election of the president.
A citizen, in bringing such a challenge, would not be required to indicate the exact number of votes that candidates ought to have obtained. Being a candidate does not change the qualification for bringing such a Petition and cannot require more than any other citizen.”
He recalled that “No one is asking Nana Addo to bring his figures or the number of votes he and other candidates got, nor indicated his figures in this petition since that would have no relevance in the court before the court.”
Accordingly, the Petitioner discharged the burden of proof that was on him.
The Petitioner avers that “the unsigned press statement was not only correcting the alleged wrong total valid votes cast figures announced by Mrs Jean Mensa in her declaration on December 9, 2020.
She also went on to adjust the votes obtained by candidates Mahama and Akufo-Addo as declared for them on December 9, 2020. Votes of other candidates were also adjusted.”
All this, Mahama said it was done outside the framework provided by CI 127 and particularly, without the involvement of the agents of the candidates, contrary to the requirement of Articles 49 (2) and (3) of the Constitution and Regulation 44 (10) of CI127.
“Paragraph 29-30 of the amended Petition are very clear on how the Press Release issued on December 10, 2020, compounds the lack of transparency, fairness and candour of the 1st Respondent (EC) in the ever-changing figures,” the Petitioner said.
Also, he said the figure in the purported “correction” as to the total valid votes cast was itself repudiated by the first Respondent (EC) by the time the answer to the Petition was filed on January 9, 2021.
“It defied logic that the 1st respondent (EC) issued a “correction” on 10th December 2020 to a figure which is now claimed to have been the actual figure purported on Form 13 on December 9, 2020.”
Mr Mahama said “in the midst of changing figures of total valid votes cast as well as votes of individual candidates, it simply cannot be said that the overall results on Form 13 were not affected, especially when the figures claimed to have been form 13 are different from figures in the “correction” on December 10 2020.”
He contended that there were discrepancies in figures provided for candidates of other parties and “the material increase of Akuffo-Addo whiles at the same time materially reducing the votes of the Petitioner clearly requires explanation.”
The former president said fundamentally, there was no evidence from the EC on the basis of which any of its contradictory claims could be accepted as “the truth.”
He held that attempt to “effect a correction by an unsigned press release is wholly untenable.”
According to the Petitioner, the testimony of the three witnesses for the Petitioner showed clearly not only the breach of the duty to be fair and candid under Article 23 of the Constitution but also the lack of due process in terms of Article 296 of the Constitution.
He submitted that when matters of breaches of the Constitution or of Statute arose before a court there was an urgency about addressing those breaches.
Mr Mahama said the conduct of the EC Chairperson in sending the agents of a major candidate who should have been present in the resolution of the outstanding issues leading to the declaration and “immediately going ahead to make the declaration without even the required steps under the Regulation 44(10) were self-evidently unreasonable.”
Latest Stories
-
Herman Suede is set to release ‘How Dare You’ on April 24
2 hours -
Heal KATH: Kuapa Kokoo, Association of Garages donate 120k to support project
2 hours -
KNUST signs MOU with Valco Trust Fund, Bekwai Municipal Hospital to build student hostel
3 hours -
The influence Ronaldo has on people, Cadman Yamoah will have same on the next generation – Coach Goodwin
3 hours -
Gender Advocate Emelia Naa Ayeley Aryee Wins prestigious Merck Foundation Awards
4 hours -
South Africa bursary scandal suspects granted bail
5 hours -
Ecobank successfully repays $500m Eurobond due April 18
5 hours -
Re: Doe Adjaho, Torgbui Samlafo IV, call for Unity among Paramountcies in Anlo
5 hours -
Extortion and kidnap – a deadly journey across Mexico into the US
5 hours -
Rihanna says fashion has helped her personal ‘rediscovery’ after having children
5 hours -
Development Bank Ghana targets GH¢1bn funding for commercial banks in 2024
5 hours -
Shatta Movement apologises to Ghana Society of the Physically Disabled after backlash
6 hours -
Sammy Gyamfi writes: Tema-Mpakadan Railway Project; A railway line to nowhere
7 hours -
Bright Simons: Is the World Bank saving or harming Ghana?
7 hours -
CAF Cup: RS Berkane banned from entering Algeria because of a map of Morocco with its Sahara
7 hours