
Audio By Carbonatix
The seven justices (and sometimes nine judges) hearing the 2020 Election Petition have been called upon on 10 occasions to rule on various issues.
These are matters that have seen lawyers representing the respondents (EC and President Akufo-Addo) take positions contrary to that of the petitioner, John Mahama.
The seven judges hearing the case are Chief Justice Kwasi Anin Yeboah, Justices Yaw Appau, Marful Sau, Nene Amegatcher, Prof. Kotey, Mariama Owusu, and Gertrude Torkonoo .
They have on two occasions been joined by Justices Amadu Tanko (both occasions) and Prof Henrietta Mensa Bonsu (once) and Lovelace Johnson (once).
The rulings so far;
All the court’s decisions in the last few weeks have been unanimous 7-0 and 9-0 on three occasions.
- First it unanimously granted the petitioner's request to amend the initial petition i.e correct minor mistakes that did not affect the substance of the petition.
Mahama’s lawyers move to correct errors in 2020 election petition
2. It unanimously dismissed a request for interrogatories to be served. These were 12 questions they wanted the EC Chairperson to answer
Supreme Court dismisses Mahama’s 12 interrogatories for the EC
3. Constituted as a 9 member panel, it unanimously dismissed a request to substitute a paragraph and add additional ground in a push by the petitioner to have the interrogatories ruling reviewed.
Allow me to demonstrate further that your ruling was contrary to law – Mahama to Supreme Court
4. This 9 member panel also unanimously dismissed the review of interrogatories ruling itself.
Supreme Court dismisses Mahama’s application to review ruling on interrogatories
5. The original 7 member panel by a unanimous decision struck out portions of the petitioner’s witness (Asiedu Nketia) statement (7 paragraphs) while maintaining 3 parts following a request by the Respondents.
Election petition: Supreme Court strikes out 7 portions of Asiedu Nketia’s statement
6. This panel also unanimously dismissed a request by the petitioner for documents to be inspected.
Supreme Court dismisses Mahama’s application to inspect 6 EC documents
7. The panel unanimously struck out 5 parts of 32 paragraphs of the petitioner’s witness statement (Mettle-Nunoo)
Supreme Court strikes out 5 paragraphs from Mettle-Nunoo’s witness statement; 27 maintained
8. The panel unanimously rejected the petitioner’s request to compel the EC to call Jean Mensa to testify
We cannot compel Jean Mensa to give evidence – Supreme Court judges
9. The panel unanimously dismissed the petitioners request to reopen his case
You cannot reopen your case – Supreme Court dismisses Mahama’s application
10. The enhanced 9 member panel dismissed the petitioner's request that it reviews its decision not to compel Jean Mensa to testify.
Jean Mensa cannot be compelled to testify – Supreme Court affirms earlier ruling
From the above, it is only on one occasion that a request by the petitioner has been wholly granted.
This was the request to correct mistakes.
The petitioner's viewpoint has been partly upheld on two occasions when it came to striking out portions of witness statements.
The legal arguments of the respondents have however swayed the judges 7 times.
Two judges are expected to join the 7 to hear another review motion seeking to set aside the court's unanimous decision that did not allow the petitioner to reopen his case.
Latest Stories
-
First Afcon, now World Cup – Senegal trapped in ‘football hell’
9 minutes -
Glasner poised for Forest job as Pereira exits
13 minutes -
UEFA will not use red cards for players who cover mouth
28 minutes -
‘You cried for DDEP victims; where are your tears for flood victims?’ – Akosua Manu to Nana Yaa Jantuah
31 minutes -
Akosua Manu says government’s first duty is to protect lives amid flood disaster, not ‘settings’
35 minutes -
Former Arsenal midfielder Cazorla retires at 41
38 minutes -
The World Cup’s free agents looking for their next move
54 minutes -
‘We want to win World Cup for him’ – Portugal carry Diogo Jota’s memory
57 minutes -
Spain beat Austria for first World Cup knockout win since 2010
1 hour -
World Cup boom falters as US hospitality jobs fall in June
1 hour -
GH¢34.5bn paid out in cocoa purchases as COCOBOD injects more cash
1 hour -
COCOBOD releases GH¢2.6m to LBCs to settle cocoa farmers
1 hour -
‘I spent $6,000 on a World Cup trip but was left stranded at the gate’
1 hour -
Google must pay €4.1bn fine for using Android to ‘block’ rivals
2 hours -
Singapore seizes $42m mansion over Nvidia chip smuggling
2 hours